Upon receiving this piece, we, the editors of praxis, verified the identity of the author/s. We respect their desire to remain anonymous, given the sensitive topic. We identified them only by a surname.
Scholars of Sinophone Studies have long critiqued imperialism, but by their actions, they need it. Sinophone Studies scholars have long argued against a world that wants colonialism, but by their actions, actually-existing colonialism isn’t worth the fuss.
If not, then why have the vast majority of Sinophone Studies scholars, particularly those in positions of leadership, refused to assume a critical public position against Howard Chiang’s acceptance of the Dan David Prize? By now, the facts regarding the Dan David Prize and Chiang’s decision are well established by the several documents disseminated in the Boycott Dan David Prize Campaign: the “Open Letter to the Society of Sinophone Studies regarding Howard Chiang’s Acceptance of the Dan David Prize”; “The Dan David Prize and Liberal Zionist Academic Washing: An Explainer”; and “History of the DDP and its Dissidents”.
Perhaps Sinophone Studies scholars merely want for courage to draw the line at a leading scholar using the Sinophone Studies project to rehabilitate collaboration with a genocidal state. Perhaps Sinophone Studies scholars believe that opposing Howard Chiang’s genocide-washing could endanger their own careers. If the latter is true, if scholars are reasonably afraid to critique their collaborationist colleague and stand for Palestinian lives, then that speaks to the unsalvageable character of Sinophone Studies as an intellectual community. But that still does not explain the silence among many, many scholars who enjoy tenure and positions of leadership in Sinophone Studies. Surely, among them, there are scholars who oppose the genocide as well as their own academic field being financially bound to collaboration with it. Have these leaders not considered that, by assuming a critical public position, they would not only claw back the credibility of Sinophone Studies, but do so in a way that offers legitimacy to the junior scholars, contingent scholars, and current graduate students who have evidently risked much in standing against Chiang’s actions?
Yet the leading lights of Sinophone Studies, always keen to announce their career milestones, stay silent. Perhaps this silence is purposive. Perhaps Sinophone studies needs the imperialist logic that has wrought the “Howard Chiang [Blood Money] Research Fund”. We may certainly dispute whether, in the past, Sinophone Studies, with its fair-weather commitments to “decenter China” and champion the “marginalized,” was a project coherent with U.S. imperialism. However, what the Chiang affair demonstrates is that Sinophone Studies has now become part of U.S.–Israeli imperialism, with its attendant pinkwashing, colonialism, and genocide. It has become this not just through the actions of Chiang (though Chiang plays a decisive role and should be duly recognized for this, his latest career milestone), but through the complicit silence of the Society of Sinophone Studies scholars and, more broadly, the unwillingness of Sinophone scholars at all levels of the academy to draw the line at genocide collaboration within their own field.
Perhaps the senior scholars who choose to stay silent on the Chiang affair should be named. They owe an explanation for their tacit complicity. But today, this is not our concern. This is, in fact, not a question of individual actions. Howard Chiang is also of little interest, as an individual. Chiang is only the symptom of a broader phenomenon in Sinophone Studies and well beyond — that of scholars who cherish their position at any and all cost to their positionality.
The positionality of Sinophone Studies has been long developed through critiques of imperialism. How quickly such critiques evaporate when a monetary award is presented that rehabilitates collaboration with the Israeli state. In accepting this money, Howard Chiang has embraced a new position as friend to imperialism. His action also makes him an implicit foe to the countless students and faculty across the United States, Europe, and beyond who have risked and often suffered consequences for demanding the end of Israeli occupation and genocide. But most egregiously, Chiang is positioned as institutionally hostile to Palestinian lives. Given this, one could be forgiven for believing that Chiang also placed himself at odds with the Society of Sinophone Studies, given its June 15, 2021 commitment to the international Boycott, Sanctions, and Divestment (BDS) movement. What a statement they composed, decrying Israel for settler-colonialism and apartheid. These declarations are only good, however, when followed by meaningful action.
Chiang’s defiance of commitments to BDS within his field and the near-categorical silence of Sinophone Studies scholars marks a transformational moment in Sinophone Studies. It signals the incorporation of U.S.–Israeli imperialism as a structuring, material condition for the future of the field. In addition, the categorical silence imposed around the Chiang affair inscribes this material condition as an ideological norm. Silence on the Chiang affair and all it importunes is no longer a question of individual temerity; it is evidently a condition for being part of the Sinophone Studies community.
This community has generally developed its intellectual project through engagements with postcolonial studies, extending to examinations of queer and trans identity in communities defined as Sinophone. This has been a salient dimension of Howard Chiang’s own scholarship. In accepting the DDP, Chiang has posed a material condition (collaboration with the Israeli state) that reconfigures queer studies within the Sinophone field. Chiang has institutionally fused queer studies to genocide rehabilitation. He does this as Israel continues its bloody colonization of the West Bank and Gaza. Chiang has therefore removed the “post” from “postcolonial,” baptizing queer studies in the blood of colonial violence.
Jasbir Puar and numerous other critics of Israeli “pinkwashing” have shown the systematic hijacking of queer identity used to legitimize Israeli authority over Palestinians (who are duly smeared as anti-queer). Chiang’s own self-named research fund is now unambiguously inscribed in that pinkwashing logic. This material collaboration by a leading figure of queer studies and its tacit acceptance by the Sinophone Studies community marks a major transformation in how we must regard queer Sinophone Studies. Howard Chiang’s pinkwashing is therefore significant –– if precedented and unexceptional (though allowing that an award be named after yourself is exceptionally tacky).
Is this what Sinophone Studies scholars want? If Howard Chiang’s actions were received with critique and reflection among the broader community of Sinophone Studies scholars, then this would be a pertinent question. In the face of enduring silence despite numerous efforts at dialogue and blistering critiques, it can only be reasonably concluded that yes, this is what the community wants. And irrespective of what individual scholars may think of what they want, this is now what Sinophone Studies is.
Howard Chiang is only a symptom of Sinophone Studies as a project bereft of a critical position on the most incisive issue of our present. Sinophone studies scholars will not critique imperialism, colonialism, and pinkwashing –– to say nothing of genocide –– when the call is coming from inside the house. Now, the material organization of Sinophone Studies is bound to its former objects of critique. In the absence of any clear evidence to the contrary, Sinophone Studies scholars are willing to accept the price of collaboration.
Of course, the true price is and always was paid by the people of Palestine. From the heights of Jade Mountain, it must be difficult to hear them.
58 Replies to “Cao, What do Sinophone Studies scholars want? ”
Very brave not sign such vitriol, full of rank attacks on Howard Chiang. Does the author/s even know what the Dan David Prize is? or who Dan David was? Do s/he/they care? It’s all about Israel, of course. Is every dollar/shekel out of Israel tarnished? If you’re boycotting this because it comes from an Israel source, then it’s time to give up your phones (and a whole hell lot of other things). From where I sit, this is pure antisemitism.
Shut uppppppppp
More bravery from virtue-signalers! If you “brave” enough to tell me to not express my opinions, then why have you not signed your screed?
It’s a mark of how astute Josh Fogel’s remarks are, that he is met with insolent and childish responses. This site’s cowardly anonymous attack on Howard Chang is indeed rank anti-semitism.
You cannot even properly spell Chiang’s last name who you tryna defend, typical white supremacist behaviour huh?
White zionists in our field are pissed about this piece because they have been exploiting the land, the culture, and the language to build their careers, just as how Israel is exploiting the land and the people in Palestine.
From river to the sea, fuck the zionists and the White supremacists in sinophone studies.
Such lovely academic writing, but who are you hiding behind anonymity? Have you ever been to the Middle East? Are you a Hamas partisan? You should go, because anything would be better than the utter ignorance of this post. (And, I sign my name!)
Joshua Fogel equates the boycotting of the Israeli government, and criticisms of institutions that launder the reputation of the Israeli government, to antisemitism. According to the IHRA definition of antisemitism, to equate the Israeli government and Israeli institutions to Jewish people around the world is profoundly antisemitic. One is therefore forced to conclude that Joshua Fogel is profoundly antisemitic.
“always”? Also, this “comment” makes no logical sense. And, yes, I do support the IHRA definition of antisemitism. Yet another courageous commenter who refuses to sign his/her/their virtue-signaling. If you truly believe this utter BS, have the courage to sign what you write. Otherwise, it’s just so much flatulence.
It is unfortunate that most readers of Mr. Fogel’s post are primarily infuriated by his provocative rhetoric but fail to address the fact that his post contains no content. Fogel asks, “Does the author/s even know what the Dan David Prize is?” Yet the second paragraph of the original article contains links to extensive information about Dan David, the Prize, and why the money associated with this particular prize is “tarnished.” Has Fogel read the second paragraph?
To Mr. Fogel: If you have a concrete disagreement with the information provided in those links, please share it.
Thank you, “Qwe,” though I’d like to know who you are. Your questions are fair. Yes, I saw all those shaded links, but I think they are based on bogus information and biased argumentation on the order of: “When did you stop beating your wide/husband?” Is the fact that no Palestinian has ever won the Dan David Prize evidence of anti-Islamic bias? How many applications have been submitted by or on the behalf of Palestinian candidates? Anything the BDS movement touches is suspect. And, I (again) suggest that, if you genuinely plan to boycott all Israeli products, then start by turning in your cell phones–and a lot of your meds. Otherwise you’re a walking contradiction..
yes every shackle in every dollar associated with the state of Israel and any Zionist organization is tarnished, because the state of Israel is engaged in the 70-year project of settler colonialism, apartheid and now genocide. there can be nothing put out in the name of that state that should be acceptable to anyone with even the hint of a conscience just as it would be utterly immoral to accept any kind of prize from the Russian government or from the Saudi or emirati government or from the US government at this point. these are governments that are literally destroying humanity. why would anyone with a brain take money from them? it’s despicable
Who are you, “Joshua Fogel”? I wish you would stop using my name.
If you care so much about Palestine, then why not put your convictions into action and go there to stand in solidarity with Palestinians, rather than hiding behind an anonymous post to launch a sweeping attack on Chang and Sinophone Studies?
Sinophone Studies has already faced sustained hostility from supporters and sympathisers of PRC imperialism. It is deeply hypocritical to weaponise Palestine as a pretext to attack an entire field of scholarship, while showing little genuine engagement with the actual struggles of Palestinians.
Solidarity is not a convenient political slogan to deploy when it suits your agenda. If your concern is genuinely with Palestinians, then demonstrate it through meaningful action and intellectual honesty, rather than using their suffering to pursue an entirely different ideological vendetta.
The post by the commentator “Wa” commits the logical fallacy of whataboutism. I agree that PRC imperialism threatens Sinophone Studies, and I also agree that those sympathetic to the Palestinian cause should do more work on the ground. Nevertheless, neither of these issues has any bearing on the question of whether scholars of Sinophone Studies should boycott the Dan David Prize. This comment essentially only deflects attention from the real issue at hand. What is the commentator afraid of? Why can they not address the actual question directly?
Not afraid. S/he/they are identifying a parallel issue of great relevance in this case.
What exactly do you consider this relevance to be? For Wa’s position to be valid, you need to prove that this relevance is such that only after Sinophone Studies has completely eliminated the threat of PRC imperialism, and only after everyone has done everything possible to support Palestinians, can Sinophone Studies scholars be asked to explain why they are unwilling to boycott the Prize. Please prove this.
Stop sullying my good name, “JOSHUA FOGEL”!
This is childish BS
How dare you call me, THE REAL JOSHUA FOGEL, childish?! I am a magnificent boomer dinosaur.
What even is this piece? Why is positions even publishing such a nonsensical screed of hateful libels? Are the editors unaware of how published pieces like this are contributing directly to the normalization, the mainstreaming, of hate, harassment, marginalization, or do they just not care? Are they unaware of how profoundly impacted students, scholars, and others are by the hate fomented by these libels – that real people, friends, colleagues, students, neighbors, are suffering very real harms because of the normalization of these hateful misrepresentations? Or do they just not care?
Why help launder such disgusting libels by publishing it as approved by the editorial committee?
As academics, I think we desperately need to do better. To do better at excising bigotry, not its targets.
Which part of this do you feel to be hateful, misleading or libelous?
Bravo! I await a response from the editors of positions.
A Response to Critics
A brief note on accusations of “bullying” and the like: the Society of Sinophone Studies (SSS) and the concerned individual at the core of this imbroglio have had several months to respond to numerous critiques and formal demands regarding the decision to accept the Dan David Prize. SSS leadership and others in the field of Sinophone Studies, to which this prize money has been institutionally joined, have chosen to maintain their silence. Silence is not neutrality; it is alignment with the status quo. Our critique is directed at this shared commitment to silence. We take issue with the broad abdication of responsibility to refuse collaboration. Efforts to paint our critique as libelous, bullying, or antisemitic are intellectually unserious and only useful insofar as they speak to the vapidity of our critics’ positions.
One reader has suggested that we decamp to Palestine. We do not subscribe to the logic that being physically present in a territory is necessary to assume a position on the genocide being conducted there (a fine nugget of cogitation).
Cao
> the Society of Sinophone Studies (SSS) and the concerned individual at the core of this imbroglio have had several months to respond to numerous critiques and formal demands regarding the decision to accept the Dan David Prize. SSS leadership and others in the field of Sinophone Studies, to which this prize money has been institutionally joined, have chosen to maintain their silence. Silence is not neutrality; it is alignment with the status quo.
This is a description of bullying. Tantamount to “I get to bully whoever I want if they don’t do what I say because Palestine is just that important.”
> Our critique is directed at this shared commitment to silence.
This is factually inaccurate. Your critique here is directed to a single human being, and a colleague of yours at that.
If you regret your post–and it seems like you are having second thoughts–then take it down. There are other ways to support Palestine.
The piece insists that tenured scholars must publicly risk their careers to denounce Chiang, yet its author hides behind anonymity. That single fact collapses the central charge that silence equals cowardice or endorsement.
Non-response is not the same as agreement. Treating the lack of statements as proof that “this is what the community wants,” or that the field is now structurally fused to U.S.–Israeli imperialism, simply does not follow. People can reject the framing of the prize, view it as one scholar’s choice, or refuse to stage political performances on demand without thereby endorsing anything.
The double standard is plain. The piece treats failure to condemn one Israeli-linked award as evidence of complicity in “genocide,” while saying nothing about the PRC’s camps, forced labor, and cultural destruction of Uyghurs and Tibetans—the very structures Sinophone Studies claims to critique. If silence on Chiang proves the field has become imperialist, the same logic would make the field’s long silence or soft framing on Xinjiang and Tibet an endorsement of Chinese imperialism. The rule is applied only one way.
The “genocide” label is asserted as fact. The ICJ has ordered provisional measures in the South Africa case but has not found that Israel is committing genocide; the required specific intent remains unproven and disputed. The war began with Hamas’s October 7 massacre and has been fought against a group that embeds among civilians. Calling this genocide while minimizing clearer cases of mass detention and erasure under the PRC is selective rhetoric, not consistent critique. Independent counts put Russian military deaths in Ukraine at roughly 280,000 confirmed by name, with broader estimates of 300,000–700,000 killed—far higher than the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry’s claim of about 70,000. Ukraine is responding to an invasion, just as Israel responded to October 7. If the logic of the piece held, Ukraine would also stand accused of genocide. It does not, because the charge is applied selectively.
What remains is a purity test aimed at one alignment and waived for the field’s original target. That is selective enforcement, not anti-imperialism. This is also the bullying of one individual. It is irresponsible and dangerous. We saw what happened with Jason Arday.
The scholars who have been vocal in noting Chiang’s embrace of genocide – namely those who signed the public letter here https://forms.gle/9NMBbUjq5r8LBBGAA – have also been absolutely vocal in critiquing the violent and exploitative policies of the PRC in their work. You must know this, of course. And you must also know that the neo-colonial extractivist policies of the PRC in Xinjiang are carried out in close partnership with Israel, through the sharing of surveillance technologies amongst other things – again, a key point that had been repeatedly by those who stand in solidarity with Palestine.
The whole point of having tenure is that it gives you a degree of institutional security whereby you can make intellectual interventions and take political stances. Tenured scholars – from Taipei to Harvard – who stand silent are absolutely failing in their stated commitments. This is not even just a matter of Chiang. When Israel began its brutal assault on the Palestinian people, letters were circulated, sit-ins were held, scholars were called upon to take a stand. The bastions of Sinophone Studies remained silent. The esteemed scholars of the Harvard East Asian Studies Department, with all their institutional and financial backing, did nothing – I guess we could call it the monster that is complicity.
And no, Chiang is not Jason Arday. The mere suggestion of that comparison is monstrous. Chiang will be fine. He will continue to fly around the world, getting pats on the back, and accepting money wherever he can find it.
Spring Bridge, you are a true coward and an antisemite. The Xinjiang surveillance and detention system which is equipped with Hikvision cameras along with “Uyghur alarm” features, the Integrated Joint Operations Platform built by CETC, facial recognition from firms like SenseTime and Megvii, DNA collection, and predictive policing, was designed and implemented by Chinese state-linked companies. Israel played no role in building or operating this system. Asserting a “close partnership” invents a connection that does not exist in order to drag the Jewish state into an atrocity it has nothing to do with.
This fits the broader pattern in your argument: you treat Israel’s war (Hamas-reported deaths in Gaza of roughly 75,000 over three years, including combatants, in a dense urban fight that began with the October 7 massacre) as uniquely genocidal and a reason for scholars to be called complicit. Meanwhile, far larger and often undercounted death tolls, such as the hundreds of thousands of confirmed or estimated deaths in the Russia-Ukraine war, hundreds of thousands in Tigray, and higher still in Syria, Yemen, Sudan, and elsewhere, receive none of the same institutional demands or “genocide” framing from the same voices. That selective application of moral standards is simply antisemitism. We all know it is backed by Qatari money, which is my Trump has been cracking down on academia. You and the rest of the people who signed the letter should be blamed for all the hardships US academia is going through right now. But it’s okay. No one cares about the Jews, and this is why hate crimes have been rising and been breaking records in the last three years. You are complicit in that too, and you probably don’t care.
I also love how you decided Howard is not Jason. What do you actually know about his mental well being, his day-to-day struggles in life? Is he a white man for you now? Absolutely ridiculouos.
so you are saying Israel is not committing genocide? Oh my goodness!
Addressing some comments.
1. BDS is a targeted boycott, it does not ask for us to boycott everything. Josh, please understand BDS before you comment on it. You can find the list if you go to their website. DDP is named as a target of PACBI (Palestinian Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel) because reasons listed in the document in this piece as well as on PACBI’s website. BDS was effective in helping to end apartheid in South Africa.
2. One does not have to live in Palestine to critique. By that logic, do all Sinophone Studies scholars have to move to Taiwan and HK, or places with significant Sinophone Studies communities? Do all critiques of China have to move back to China to critique China? (This is the kind of tankie defence of China, that China critiques have no legitimacy if they live elsewhere). I am surprised that some commenters would deploy the same rhetoric here.
3. In terms of why not also talk about Uyghur or Tibet. This is about Palestine and using the other two oppressed minorities to delegitimize the concerns of the letter is harmful. Granted, there is unequal attention on the global left in terms of the Uyghur genocide, we need to do better. But this is not the topic of this letter at all. The argument seems to be a straw person argument that does not deal with the substance of the argument in the letter. As I read it, Howard is not the point at all, the key point is academia and its complicity with Israel’s academic washing of its genocide.
4. I have no interests in debating the genocide of Palestinians in Gaza, just like I have no interests in debating the genocide of Uyghurs and the genocide of trans people globally. I am disgusted by some of the comments that still question the genocide.
Let me respond where I can to the comments by “Niu” (whoever you might be): (1) BDS has been a shapeshifting phenomenon; when its massive array of internal contradiction and the Keffiyeh crowd realized they’d have to give up their cell phones and other bourgeois amenities, it cleverly cut them out of the deal, but bottom line is that by making Israel the bogeyman of the world, it basically self-identified as antisemitic; BDS was not an acronym vis-a-vis South Africa, if memory serves, but many on the far left would like to convince themselves that they brought down the apartheid regime. Calling Israel an apartheid state is a disgrace before the millions of South African blacks who suffered miserably under the apartheid regime. (2) True, you don’t have to live there, but it would help. Have you been to any Muslim majority country? Witnessed any elections there? I thought so. (4) If you wish to witness (at a distance, of course) real genocide, look at what is happening in Yemen or Syria or many other places. I’m no advocate of war, but all you BDS supporters somehow missed the news of October 7, 2023–that was only attempted genocide in the region. I’m old enough to have lived through and participated in the civil rights movement in the 1960s–on a SNCC project in Arkansas (1965); the deep South was genuine, homegrown apartheid, terror is you were black.
I’m THE REAL JOSHUA FOGEL and I do not endorse this message.
why is Palestine becoming a screen for the waging of critical China studies vs. Sinophone studies and campist discussions on what constitutes anti-imperialism? there is an exceptionalization of Palestine here, an “empire of critique,” that overlooks all the other forms of non-spectacular imperial violences that are being enacted concurrently, including by the Chinese state. it’s not a zero sum game. sometimes to oppose one form of imperialism requires complicity with another. all of us that work in US institutions are funded by US settler colonial and imperial money, not to mention how much work in China studies has been funded by PRC money.
A Further Response
We will not engage with genocide denialism and can only wonder at the profound ugliness of those contesting our position by such means. Other efforts to trivialize the Palestine question at the core of our intervention –– the whataboutism, claims of “using” Palestine –– reflect the narrow minds and desiccated spirits that plague our present. These critics cannot think. They cannot think Palestine as anything other than a prop, a test of “virtue,” a slogan. They do not think what it means for our field that our colleagues –– indeed, their colleagues ––– have been slaughtered by the IDF. They scramble to defend Chiang’s actions when he is an institutionally insulated, lavishly resourced colleague; meanwhile, colleague Refaat Alareer’s murder lies beyond their empire of sympathy. The IDF has razed Gaza’s schools to the ground, murdered students, blasted communities to pieces, scattered its archives to the winds. But they cannot conceive how normalizing collaboration with institutions ensconced in this settler-colonial project is a critical matter for our present, past, and possible futures.
The Society of Sinophone Studies made clear, in their June 2021 statement “SSS Solidarity with Palestine” available online, their commitment in the face of such brutality:
“The Society for Sinophone Studies stands in solidarity with Palestinians and the Palestinian movement for justice and freedom from Israel settler colonialism. We condemn the ongoing occupation and blockade of the Gaza Strip and the ethnic cleansing waged against Palestinians. This includes the most recent campaign commenced in early May 2021, consisting of the forced removal of Palestinians from their homes in East Jerusalem, the storming of Muslim religious sites and Palestinian hospitals, the bombings of Gaza that have killed over 200 Palestinians many of whom are children, and the attacks against Palestinian protestors by settlers and Israeli military.”
Our intervention does not pose Palestine as a “purity test” for the academy. Rather, we ask what do Sinophone Studies scholars want. We do so to hold the Society of Sinophone Studies to account for its own commitment to the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement that calls to refuse the Dan David Prize. Critics who otherwise seek to re-litigate the genocide or the BDS movement can take their arguments to the Society of Sinophone Studies.
We think with Palestine, and we expect the Society of Sinophone Studies to honor their commitments to do so as well. More broadly, we hope that the broader community of Sinophone Studies scholars will find means to break the silence looming over this affair.
Now, we have made our critique. The genocide apologists have come to the defense (“with friends like these”). Society of Sinophone Studies scholars, Howard Chiang, and others scholars of Sinophone Studies and beyond: where do you stand?
CAO
If you want to do your boycott, ok, go ahead.
But don’t try to bully people into going along with your boycott.
People make their own decisions.
I am amazed by how people who are supposed to be either “scholars” or at least highly educated seem to lose any basic reading comprehension when it comes to this. Nobody is bullying anybody. This is one association that not only declared itself to be centered on anti-colonialism but also actively and overtly declared its support of BDS, and yet has not said a word about this issue. And that, in the end, questions their own commitment to anti-colonialism.
The problem has been clearly stated. Repeatedly.
You can deny the genocide. Absurd, but not the point.
You can quibble with BDS. Not the point.
That was not the position of the Society for Sinophone Studies. They supported BDS.
The SSS performed solidarity with the Palestine struggle and then decided to be silent about the prize. So one wonders, what is the nature of their anti-colonialism and anti-imperialism?
And people, you are supposed to know how to read texts. That is your only skill.
It seems to me that the advancement of this cause is best served by the kind of clear, to-the-point writing exemplified by “NotKevinCarrico!” above. Sure, the basic point is there in Cao’s original piece, but I wish it had been written in a way that is less alienating to those who don’t already fully agree with the author
Speak for yourself. I for one have many skills beyond “reading texts.”
To provide one example, I can also assess and evaluate texts and their reception. Sometimes when readers respond negatively to what you have written, it is actually not because the readers can’t read or are bad people. It’s because what you have written is silly.
For example, when an author claims that Howard Chiang is “baptizing queer studies in the blood of colonial violence,” well… I can assess that there is no point in trying to have a discussion with such an author. No wonder you want to be anonymous! It’s quite embarrassing.
I appreciate Cao’s critical intervention and strongly agree that it is hypocritical and unethical for a scholar to position their work as anti-imperialist while accepting funding from the Dan David Prize. In 2021, when the Society of Sinophone Scholars released their Palestine Solidarity Statement and committed to the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, specifically including the academic boycott, they took a clear stance connecting their critique of colonialism with their solidarity with Palestine.
The full statement is still available online here: https://rhombus-chartreuse-4fnk.squarespace.com/palestinian-solidarity-statement
For a member of the Society of Sinophone Scholars to accept the Dan David Prize clearly violates the commitments made in that statement. Some readers might disagree with Cao’s rhetoric, but his central argument is unimpeachable: Sinophone Scholars must choose. Either Howard Chiang must turn down the Dan David Prize or the Society of Sinophone Scholars must retract its statement of solidarity with Palestine. If it does the latter, I think it should also refrain from positioning itself as anti-imperialist in any meaningful way.
Comments accusing the author of antisemitism are despicable and only serve to distract from the central issue. Scholars working in the field of Sinophone studies must speak up and demand that their research not become complicit in the very structures of settler-colonialism and imperialism which they are working to critique.
Ian Weiner
While I completely and categorically disagree with everything in your statement–and at least you had the decency to sign your name–there is a third option: Howard can leave the Sinophone group, upon having accepted the Dan David Prize. That’s his choice.
I would encourage to Sinophone group withdraw its pro-BDS statement, which I fully believe is antisemitic, despite any number of Jews who have signed on to that “despicable” movement.
You cannot even bring yourself to say the words “Palestine” or “Palestinians”. You make reference to “Islamic bias” and “Muslim-majority countries”, which is a complete obfuscation, precisely because of how “Muslim majority” US client states in the region have themselves been complicit with Israel’s brutality. This is the genocide of a people – many of whom are Christians, or who have no faith at all. You cannot bring yourself even to recognize the name of that people – you too, Fogel, are a participant in that genocide in the way you refuse even to acknowledge that there *is* a Palestinian people.
Or maybe I’m wrong. Say it, Fogel. Recognize that there is a people, a nation, called Palestine.
Feel free to call me Josh, whoever you are hiding behind that glyph. I never used the expression “Islamic bias” or any of the other ones you claim. I’m looking on a map now for a country called “Palestine,” and unless it’s been completely geo-washed, I can’t find it. Of course, there is a people called “Palestinian,” but what in the world does that mean. Many of them voted last week in the elections in a country–let me look back at the map–yes, for a country, right here, called Israel. In fact, those Palestinians may have a major role to play in the next Israeli govt. So, now I’m a genocidaire, am I? You make such a libelous claim and hide behind anonymity. Such cowardice is astounding. Who the hell are you?
Well argued, CAO! Thank you for speaking out.
another coward
Well argued, CAO. Thanks for speaking out.
I’m retired, unconnected, and insulted that you would assume I would retaliate. Sounds like projection to me, something people on your side of the issue would do.
For those of us who have endured, for years, the bullying, the doxxing, the attempts at silencing, and the threats to our persons and our families because of our support for Palestine and our criticisms of Zionism (a political ideology) and the state of Israel (a political entity), it is truly a bizzarro world when someone as astute and as generous as Joshua Fogel (and I mean that really truly, since we go way way back and have agreed on nothing ever — not on Palestine, not on China, not on a single thing — and yet we can retain a working relationship and even enjoyably eat a meal together when the occasion calls for it) can imply that there are no consequences to revealing one’s identity when engaging with this topic. I have done so for years, have been on the Canary Mission denunciation site since its inception, and yes, I am a full tenured professor and I have been beset by hate mail and attempts to destroy my career and reputation for a very long time. I sign and always have signed my name because I can. I sign my name because the hate that spews about any criticism of Israel does not frighten me, even if it is massively unsettling.
Cao can and should remain anonymous. Those who support them and who wish to be anonymous for whatever reason should not be berated for so doing. The bullying here is coming from one direction only, and it is not from Cao, positionspolitics editors, or anyone associated with support for Palestine. The bullying is coming from those who willfully have miscontrued Cao’s text. The call here is for Sinophone Studies to clarify its politics, and either to disavow its founding raison d’etre or Howard Chiang, who has betrayed the politics of Sinophone Studies by his acceptance of the Dan David Prize.
Let me say that I think the vitriol has run its course.
One thing Rebecca and I agree upon is that we almost never agree on anything and still remain mutually respectful. There was a time not so long ago when those of us who opposed our university’s policies or the US government were adamant that our names would appear. It was a point of “pride.” That’s why I have said repeatedly that taking a sharp position and/or attacking someone while hiding behind a pseudonym is cowardice. We saw a couple of years ago when the KKKefeiyah crowd was whining about being sanctioned by their universities for involvement with the encampments or other obstructive behavior. Late breaking news: the whole point of civil disobedience is getting sanctioned or arrested to heighten attention to one’s cause.
As a knowledgeable retired professor, you surely know the price some students paid for courageously putting their names forward to lead a perfectly peaceful encampment? If you don’t know, let me tell you: Suspended by the university, targeted by ICE, and threatened by the university administration to cut their funding, etc. For a middle-class white man enjoying a nice pension, it may be hard for you to understand how putting one’s name forward can be anything beyond a “point of pride;” for many others, especially people of color, it can cost everything.
Can you all have been completely ignorant of the potential consequences of your actions? If the leadership encouraged participation in the encampment without revealing possible downsides, they should probably be drawn and quartered by the rank and file. Actions have consequences. True, the Trump administration came down like a ton of bricks. But, that’s nothing like what many suffered during the civil rights movement–many blacks and whites were murdered (to refresh your memory). As I wrote above I worked for a short time on a SNCC project in small-town Arkansas in which my father was involved. So, don’t talk to me about being “a middle-class white man, enjoying a nice pension”–you don’t know anything about me.
I understand that PhD students (like me) and early-career scholars worry about professional risks when speaking publicly. I also disagree with the suggestion that critics of Israel should go to Palestine themselves. And I do not think this is antisemitism.
However, so far, I have seen no evidence that any senior scholar has threatened to retaliate against those who disagree with them. And I think we should also be very cautious about assuming that way because of a larger question: What kind of academic culture are we creating if we repeatedly suggest to graduate students and junior scholars that openly criticizing senior colleagues is professionally dangerous? If PhD students and early-career scholars are unwilling to take any risk, will we still have the courage to publish academic criticism when we discover serious problems with senior scholars’ scholarly arguments? (For many scholars, having their academic work discredited may be far more serious than a disagreement over political views.)
In addition, Cao demands that Howard Chiang sacrifice a prestigious academic award and $300k in prize money in the name of resisting imperialism. Yet the potential risk to the author’s own academic career (in the United States, an IMPERIAL POWER) is considered a good justification for anonymity. This is somewhat ironic, and I believe it undermines the article’s credibility, though it does not invalidate the argument, which I still think is worth discussing.
Being in the belly of the beast doesn’t mean one has to root for the beast. There’s no shortage of precedents for anti-imperial struggle within imperial powers. (My pseudonym is the title of a book worth checking out!)
I find it amusing to see the suggestion that we compare the “sacrifice” a tenured professor would make by giving up the DDP ($300k) with the sacrifices many academics have actually endured for speaking out against the genocide of the Palestinian people. (Professor Rebecca Karl is not the only one who has received harassment and death threats. Check out the AAUP’s YouTube channel to hear from scholars who have lost funding, teaching positions, tenure, etc.)
What I mean is that, from my perspective, the price CAO may have to pay for going public is not comparable to an additional $300k that would allow a full professor to take a nice long sabbatical focused on some decolonial queer study.
As a PhD student myself, I sympathize with CAO’s decision to remain anonymous. Given the nature of my research, it is quite likely that members of the Society of Sinophone Studies, perhaps even Professor Howard Chiang himself, will sit on the boards of fellowships I’m applying to or may apply to in the future. That’s something I have to consider, and I can easily imagine CAO has/have similar concerns.
I’m staying anonymous for now, but that doesn’t mean I’m entirely risk-averse. I’ve gone to rallies and signed open letters when I could, and I’m considering writing something under my real name when I can. I believe CAO is/are doing the same. I don’t think carefully evaluating the current political environment and doing what is within one’s capacity is cowardly or contributes to a negative academic culture. It’s a practical, sustainable strategy for continuing anti-imperial struggles.
I have to agree that your comment about “something ironic” has a point. Anyone who fights an anti-imperial fight while living in an empire and enjoying its benefits is always already complicit. Even so, I don’t think the answer is to fall back on whataboutism and go along with the empire. I suspect everyone serious about decolonial studies has to constantly undertake a Foucauldian investigation of their innermost self, a self that has too often come to mirror the thought and actions of a colonial power.
“As a PhD student myself, I sympathize with CAO’s decision to remain anonymous. Given the nature of my research, it is quite likely that members of the Society of Sinophone Studies, perhaps even Professor Howard Chiang himself, will sit on the boards of fellowships I’m applying to or may apply to in the future. That’s something I have to consider, and I can easily imagine CAO has/have similar concerns.”
I sympathize with it too. But again, I don’t quite see why this risk is not comparable to a full professor turning down $300k. To me, it sounds very comparable. And that is exactly my point: whenever we publicly criticize the scholarship of a senior scholar, we take on risk. If we foster an atmosphere in which such risks are seen as something no one should bear, then we are indeed creating a bad academic culture. And let’s not forget that for many scholars who study the PRC, doing fieldwork in mainland China carries political risk. Political risk is nothing unusual in our field.
As for those who have lost their jobs for supporting Palestine, I admire their courage very much. But my comment was directed at this article, not at them. In publishing it anonymously, the author has taken on essentially NO risk, while demanding that another scholar give up concrete benefits. All I am saying is that this significantly undermines the article’s credibility.
Yes, the general proposition that one can struggle against an empire from within it is of course correct. But it applies differently to different people. Palestinians under Israeli rule and Black Americans have no choice but to struggle from within. However, for many of us who seek benefits (funding, resources) within the American higher education system, being here is to some extent our own choice. That choice is not entirely unjustifiable, but I am wary of anyone who makes this choice while holding others to an extremely high standard of moral purity. If someone is unwilling to risk even the benefits they gain from imperial institutions (such as American fellowships and academic promotion), yet makes strong, anti-imperialist demands of moral purity on others, those demands, if not hypocritical, will at least appear ineffective to readers.
What an embarrassing spectacle for all involved, especially the editors of positions. Is the descent into the same inane, endless “debate” about Palestine and BDS a satisfying outcome for this mess? Are there really so many anglophone scholars of sinophone and Chinese studies that the supposed goal of this editorial, made clear only after several “updates” in this catastrophe of a comments section, could not have been accomplished by simply talking to someone, anyone, involved with SSS? If public spectacle was needed, could positions not have simply signal-boosted the statement accompanying the original Open Letter to the SSS? Instead, they have chosen to stand awkwardly behind (publishing and yet apparently not endorsing, “just asking questions” style) an anonymous missive that manages to regurgitate all of the usual bad-faith critiques of sinophone studies, from the very first sentence questioning whether the entire field “needs imperialism.” Yes, the SSS should probably say something about Chiang’s acceptance of the prize. But this piece implies that, not only is Chiang still a board member of the SSS, but that Chiang’s prize money is somehow bankrolling not only a (as far as I can tell non-existent) “Howard Chiang Research Fund”, but the SSS itself and, somehow, the entirety of sinophone studies as an academic field. What does positions want? To seek clarity on the SSS’s commitment to BDS, as all of the subsequent follow-ups to this piece insist? To get into a public flame-war with notable academic Zionists, as appears to have been the only real consequence of the piece? Or just to repeat the same ill conceived “criticisms” of sinophone studies that have already been refuted so many times, only this time with the added weight of some new sense of moral superiority?
Some of us have repeatedly asked Sinophone Studies Society folks to weigh in and clarify. They have remained resolutely silent on the issue, either of Howard Chiang’s prize or of their past and present political stands. The idea of writing the piece, I’m pretty sure, was not to smoke out anyone from the woodwork; I quite sure that the idea of posting Cao’s piece was to call out an increasingly powerful wing of the field whose claims to political intervention and whose actual political hypocrisy have been hidden in plain sight.
Not sure why taking a position in our e-journal is deemed so embarrassing by the anonymous post above. Positions has always been clear, forthright, and above-board about our politics; the founding statement of the print journal was written as a political intervention into the field of study and is quite specific on this. The journal’s run for more than three decades now has been quite clear as well. The launching of the web journal is also clear. (This is not to say that anyone is responsible for the Cao piece other than Cao and those of us who ok’d its publication in the praxis section of the e-journal.) Why should we hide our engagement in the field of Asia studies as it is currently being constituted globally, or our concern about the politics of the world we live in today? Why should we not launch a frank conversation, even when the politics of the matter are bound to elicit pushback? Should we be silent?
It is embarrassing to publish a poorly written, incoherent diatribe, and to repeatedly fail to acknowledge the very obvious limitations and biases of the piece. It’s reframing the argument against Howard Chiang’s acceptance of the prize in the least constructive possible way, by implicating an entire field of research and alluding to shadowy conspiracy theories to use “blood money” to fund it, when others have already expressed a much clearer position. And it has led to an even more ridiculous flame war in the comments section. Congratulations for repeatedly asking “Sinophone Studies Society folks” to weigh in and clarify, though!
I do appreciate the more constructive comments in this conversation, certain pretty glaring examples aside. Some of the more recent discussion has been about the ethics of the anonymity of the author. I would actually like to point out some additional issues around the issue of anonymity:
1) the fact that Cao does not name which Sinophone Studies scholars, sometimes it’s Sinophone Studies scholars, so presumably any person sympathetic to the continued existence of the Sinophone, occasionally “senior scholars”. It’s pretty hilarious that someone who remains hidden due to a fear of innuendo and rumour is propagating widespread and indiscriminate innuendo and rumour. Ok Cao, so when you say Sinophone studies scholars, who are you talking about? Are you talking about the current board members Alvin Wong and Erin Huang (both recently tenured) or Jannis and Wenchi Li who are not tenured and in Li’s case hold no tenure track position at all? Are you talking about former board members like EK Tan and Brian Bernards who are no longer on the board of SSS? Are you actually talking about Shu-mei Shih? What is keeping you, given that you’re hiding your identity, from actually naming names if the point is holding people to account?
And obviously the point is that you don’t actually want to name individual people or hold them accountable because you actually want to invalidate the discipline of Sinophone Studies for the same geopolitical reasons that this is always attempted by using Palestinians as a convenient excuse. You mention Palestinians about half as much as you repeat the claim that Sinophone Studies is pro imperialism. I think that’s pretty interesting. Also while you link to an informative website about people who have protested the acceptance of this award (and for the record I don’t think Chiang should have accepted it and will never think the same of him again),no one has said that Asian American studies, or Gender studies or whichever discipline is invalid because one person made a short sighted and self serving decision. People protested against this person and the decision they made, which I think is extremely valid and frankly should be done.
2) Can we talk about how positions is moderating the comments section and is allowing multiple sock puppet accounts to impersonate and mock people who disagree with the author/s? Now to be fair, one of those people is Asian Studies’ version of Uncle Ruckus and mocks genocide because they believe the only state that is legitimate is if it’s on a map or whatever, but If you’re “just asking questions” sorry your bias is showing. And also it’s 2026, how are you allowing people to troll a blog comments section with obviously fake names like it’s 1993? What an absolute gong show.
Signed,
A person you’ve asked to peer review submissions multiple times and you can be dead sure I’m never going to do that again