subscribe   about us   journal    

Check out our paideia section - Winner of the CELJ 2024 Best Digital Feature Award

Luka Lei Zhang reviews Federico Picerni, Chinese Worker Writers: The Social and Textual Practice of the Picun Literature Group

Federico Picerni, Chinese Worker Writers: The Social and Textual Practice of the Picun Literature Group, Routledge, 2026

In July 2026, Chinese delivery worker poet Wang Jibing was named a laureate of the Lu Xun Literary Prize, one of the highest honors in Chinese literature, bringing waves of media coverage and public discussion of workers and literature. At a moment of expanding scholarly interest in Chinese working-class cultural practices, the relative scarcity of book-length studies devoted specifically to Chinese worker writers renders Federico Picerni’ s Chinese Worker Writers: The Social and Textual Practice of the Picun Literature Group particularly timely. The global and domestic popularity of the Picun Literature Group (PLG), a group located on the outskirts of Beijing that dedicates itself to nurturing migrant workers’ writing, also calls for such a book project, one that helps us understand, in Picerni’s words, “the meaning and main features of working-class cultural activity in China today… (p1)” 

Workers’ literature, or more arguably, working-class literature, has a long and rich history in the Chinese context. The abundance of migrant worker literature in recent decades has revived debates regarding the “organic and dialectical relationship” between workers and literature (p4). Scholarly inquiries often center on the legacy of Party-groomed worker writers of the 1950s to 1970s, the relatively quiet years of the reform era, and the emergence of migrant worker writing in the industrial Pearl River Delta since the 1990s. Whether and how to connect pre- and post-1980s workers’ literature remains a vexed question that Picerni engages productively throughout the book.

Picerni’s project should be highly applauded for two major aspects. First, in examining the PLG as a collective and its writers’ literary works, he deftly employs Maghiel van Crevel’s triad of context, text, and metatext from Chinese Poetry in Times of Mind, Mayhem, and Money (2008) as the framework of the book. In doing so, he not only contributes to theoretical discussions on “what constitutes workers’ literature and a worker writer,” but also updates our understanding of workers’ writing through eloquent textual analysis of five representative migrant worker writers and, more importantly, through solid fieldwork from 2014 to 2020, combining observations of collective activities, engagement in study groups, and conversations with worker writers and cultural mediators. Although fieldwork is uncommon in literary studies, Picerni’s book shows it is indispensable for answering his core research questions regarding the “formative process of the worker writer”: “what kind of strategies they deploy to claim their literary dignity, what sort of obstacles they encounter, and ultimately, who defines what a ‘worker author’ and ‘worker-authored literature’ are” (p 4).

Central to this framework is Picerni’ s adoption of Terry Eagleton’s concept of the literary mode of production (LMP), which illuminates the process of literary creation as “a unity of certain forces and social relations of literary production in a particular social formation” (Eagleton 2006, 45, cited on p. 8). By situating worker authors within the LMP, Picerni moves beyond the text itself to examine the full array of authors, publishers, mediators, and institutions that shape literary production and reception. For worker authors, who occupy what Fang Wei calls the position of “outsider writers” (waiwei zuojia 外围作家)with little political and economic capital but high aesthetic principles, the LMP framework foregrounds the structural inequalities that condition their access to literary recognition. Picerni shows that for the PLG and its members, literary practices are constantly negotiated under complex influences, above all what he calls “the role of mediators”: “individuals who are not part of the group itself and come from other contexts within Beijing’s cultural establishment, such as literary journals, cultural bodies, universities and so on” (p69). This insight resonates with van Crevel’s concept of the “lucky break,” the factors, often personal patronage, that enable an author to enter the literary field with some chance of success.

Second, Picerni’s notion of “the worker author as method,” or an “author-based approach,” brings each PLG worker writer to the table—Fan Yusu (范雨素), Xiao Hai (小海), Xu Liangyuan (徐良园), Li Ruo (李若), and Wan Huashan (万华山)—showing not only their formative process of becoming writers but also what they write and for whom. Here, his rich and original textual analysis stands out: covering each writer’s aesthetic style and genre in detail and demonstrating why their writing matters through powerful close readings, he situates their writing in the cultural and literary history of China. His analysis of Fan Yusu’s viral memoir illuminates how the intersection of literary merit and digital virality produced a new mode of reception for worker writing; his reading of Xiao Hai’ s poetry traces the influence of Haizi and Bob Dylan to show how the worker poet appropriates canonical and popular references alike; and his examination of Wan Huashan’s autofiction navigates the productive tension between factual experience and fictional creation.

Chapter 1, “Can Workers Write?,” traces a genealogy of working-class literary production in China from the early twentieth century to the present, organized around the foundational question of whether workers can write, and who counts as a worker writer. Picerni begins with the Confucian division of labour between those who work with their brains and those who work with their brawn, showing how literature was historically the exclusive domain of the literati, preserved through classical Chinese. The New Culture Movement’s promotion of vernacular Chinese (baihua) opened the first crack in this monopoly, yet May Fourth literature remained largely the product of intellectuals writing about, rather than as, common people. The proletarian literature movement of the late 1920s and 1930s, led by the League of Left-Wing Writers, was likewise written not by actual proletarian writers, hardly possible given widespread illiteracy, but by politically committed intellectuals; the Yan’an Talks institutionalized the intellectual-mass relationship, and worker-peasant-soldier literature was largely produced by professional writers under Party guidance. The chapter’s second half turns to post-1980s migrant worker (dagong) literature in the Pearl River Delta, from Yang Honghai’s promotion of dagong literature as a regional trademark to worker-run journals like Migrant Worker Poet (2001) and anthologies such as My Verses (2015). A central tension is whether dagong literature should be connected to the pre-1980s tradition; here, Picerni surveys critics including Qin Xiaoyu, Wu Ji, and Liu Dongwu, showing how the by/for/about triptych remains operative across periods, before addressing the persistent dichotomy between social relevance and artistic quality.

Chapter 2 shifts from the national-historical context to the specific social and institutional ecology of Picun, a chengzhongcun (urban village) on Beijing’s eastern outskirts and home to roughly 30,000 migrant residents. Picerni traces how three young migrant workers, Sun Heng, Xu Duo, and Wang Dezhi, moved to Picun in 2005 and founded the Migrant Workers Home (Gongyou zhi jia), the “mother organization” of the PLG, whose mission was to produce a culture that migrant workers could claim as their own, captured in the slogan: “Without our culture, we have no history; without our history, we have no future.” Its activities included the New Workers Art Troupe performing at construction sites and factories; the Tongxin Experimental School for migrant children; the Tongxin Fair Shop; the Museum of Labour Culture (2008–2023), a grassroots alternative to state-run labour museums; and annual cultural festivals. These activities represented an ambitious project of cultural appropriation, withworkers seizing the means of cultural creation to re-humanize themselves and narrate their own history. A key section addresses the role of mediators, individuals from Beijing’s cultural establishment who guide the group’s study sessions and open channels to publication, such as Zhang Huiyu and Shi Libin. The chapter also traces the PLG’s institutional evolution—the founding of the journal New Workers’ Literature in 2018 and the shift from dagong (打工) to xin gongren (新工人). It closes with the threats to Picun’s existence: gentrification campaigns, the 2017 Daxing fire and subsequent mass evictions of migrants labelled “low-end population,” and the 2023 demolition of the Museum of Labour Culture.

Whether the group’s decade-long experiment in working-class cultural creativity is nearing its end, however, is a matter of debate. Reviewing Benjamin Kindler’s Writing to the Rhythm of Labor, Christopher Connery remarks that “the movement to foster a worker’s culture, represented by Picun and a handful of other NGOs, had mostly collapsed by the end of the 2010s, victim to both state repression as well as developments internal to the groups themselves” (Connery 2025). Picerni’s book offers a detailed, if implicit, response to this judgment. Viewed from within the literary mode of production rather than from the vantage of its most visible institutions, what looks like collapse appears as a recurring condition of precarity that the group has repeatedly absorbed and outlived. The PLG survived the eviction wave of 2017–18 through negotiation with local authorities; after the museum’s demolition in 2023, its classes moved to the Tongxin school; when the school was torn down in the summer of 2025, they moved online; and when the group was evicted from its historic courtyard in June 2025, “they quickly found a new place, but the situation has not fundamentally stabilised” (p1). Picerni is candid that “the balance of forces remains extremely asymmetric and ultimately unfavourable” (p. 84). Yet the group has kept meeting, and its writers keep writing. On the evidence of this book, “collapse” better describes the fate of the movement’s institutions than of its literary practice, the practice that, in Connery’s own closing words, “holds open the space where the seeds of social transformation could sprout.”

Chapter 3, the first chapter of Part II, examines Fan Yusu, whose memoir “I Am Fan Yusu” went viral in April 2017, accumulating over three million reads within days and making her the public face of the PLG. An avid reader from Xiangyang, Hubei, Fan had written nothing before joining the group but possessed impressive literary knowledge ranging from Chinese classics to Borges, Calvino, and Kafka. Picerni analyzes the memoir’s literary construction, its non-linear progression, analepses, crafted character profiles, and its thematization of fate (mingyun) as both personal misfortune and structural condition. Picerni reads it alongside Lu Xun’s “New Year’s Sacrifice” and “A Madman’s Diary,” showing how Fan employs children as metaphors for larger questions of culture and education. The chapter also addresses the reception surrounding Fan’s virality: new media enabled a non-specialist author to reach a mass readership, but the identity-driven framing (peasant woman, migrant worker) threatened to reduce her work to raw testimony. Picerni argues that Fan’s work is not merely mimetic self-ethnography but a creative, powerfully subjective representation that overcomes the dichotomy between social relevance and artistic significance, situating her conception of literature as personal cultivation rather than political instrument.

Chapter 4 turns to Xiao Hai (pen name of Hu Liushuai), one of the PLG’s most prolific and active authors. Born in 1987 in Shangqiu, Henan, he left school at fourteen and spent years on assembly lines in Shenzhen, Ningbo, and Suzhou. His pen name pays tribute to the poet Haizi, whose mytho-poetic universe centred on the sun and agriculture profoundly shapes his imagery, alongside Allen Ginsberg’s Howl and Bob Dylan’s music. A key section analyzes Xiao Hai’s autobiographical essay “Confessions of a Failed Over-age Young Man,” which constructs a persona of self-deprecating honesty, a worker who cannot afford a car, a flat, or a partner, yet refuses to merely complain. Picerni then examines his poetic practice through Michelle Yeh’s concept of the “cult of poetry,” a religious-like devotion to verse that polarizes the mundane world against the divine world of poetry and provides close readings of recurring tropes: the sun (Haizi’s influence reimagined as poetry itself), the “iron moon” nodding to Xu Lizhi, wheat, wings, and ruins. Xiao Hai’s case, Picerni argues, illustrates how poetry functions as both personal salvation and public assertion of creative autonomy, even as the poet remains “one foot planted in the factory.”

Chapter 5 examines Xu Liangyuan, born in 1965 in Dawu county, Hubei, who followed a typical migrant trajectory: leaving school after the junior middle level, working in a local ferrosilicon factory, then migrating to Shenyang, Guangdong, and eventually Beijing’s construction sites. Unlike Xiao Hai’s factory-centred poetics, Xu’s poetry is deeply engaged with classical Chinese poetry (Tang and Song) and the cultural memory of pre-1978 working-class culture. His collection Wild Grass By the City (2017) deliberately echoes Lu Xun’s Wild Grass, just as Xiao Hai’s Howl of the Factory echoes Ginsberg. Picerni highlights Xu’s unique position within the PLG: while worker poets often frame labour through trauma and alienation, Xu frequently portrays it with dignity and even grandeur, depicting construction workers as creators of monuments with “reinforced concrete irrigating our bones,” echoing the Mao-era slogan “labour is most glorious.” Picerni traces how Xu redeploys tropes from political lyricism but reverses their direction: rather than going from the periphery to Beijing, Xu’s worker poet goes from Beijing back to the countryside, creating what Picerni calls “twisted echoes from the Maoist past,” not nostalgia, but a negotiation with reality in which the memory of socialism serves as an imagined counterweight to the contemporary commodification of labour. Close readings of “An Unskilled Labourer from Sichuan,” “The Oxherd on the Run,” and “Brother Earthworm” further display Xu’s composite imagery, which Picerni reads as perfectly mirroring the situation of post-Mao workers’ poetry as a whole.

Chapter 6 examines Li Ruo, a pen-named “factory girl” from Xinyang, Henan, born in the 1970s. Li Ruo stands out as one of the few women in the PLG who worked in factories rather than as a domestic worker; her literary production was intensely tied to in-person participation in the group: when she returned to Henan in 2017 to marry, her writing drastically declined, a living example of the PLG’s crucial role in sustaining members’ literary creativity. Picerni situates Li Ruo within the tradition of native-soil (xiangtu) literature and contemporary nonfiction: unlike earlier native-soil writers who were urban intellectuals portraying the countryside as “Other,” Li Ruo writes as someone who has personally endured the experiences she describes, bridging journalism, social investigation, and literary craft. Close readings of “Hometown—a dream-poem,” in which the exhausted factory worker shrinks back to infant size seeking her mother’s swaddling, and “A New Lament for Peasants,” which reworks a classical poetic form to address contemporary rural dispossession, exemplify her use of intimate nature imagery and concrete, fast-paced free verse, with inanimate objects (a “cabbage with a cold,” a “brick gone crazy”) serving as emotional metaphors. Picerni also highlights the gender dimension, factory line work, the stench of glue, and reproductive labour, arguing that Li Ruo’s urban native-soil writing represents a distinctive contribution to the PLG’s corpus.

Chapter 7 examines Wan Huashan, a charismatic figure who became a leading PLG member and editor of New Workers’ Literature. Born around 1989, Wan left high school and spent ten years working in factories across the Pearl River Delta, Zhejiang, and Shandong. His autobiographical account, provocatively titled “Quit High School, Worked Ten Years, Now I’m the Editor-in-Chief of a Literary Journal,” is constructed around the pursuit of a “literary dream” requiring escape from factory life, a pursuit Chun Chun Ting (2023) deems “elitist,” suggesting a dilemma between class mobility and authenticity claims. Picerni provides a theoretical framework for autofiction and analyzes three of Wan’s works across a spectrum of referentiality: “One Night at Sun Island,” the most avant-garde, places a first-person narrator in a surreal industrial landscape evoking Ding Ling’s 1930s factory reportage; “Li ‘Cultivated Talent’ Zhiguo,” a piece of reportage about Wan’s maternal uncle, explores the disillusionment of a rural intellectual; and “Pi Houzi” most successfully balances facts with fictional creation, set against the backdrop of the 2017 Daxing fire and migrant evictions. Picerni argues that Wan’s case reveals the “worker-author subject in crisis,” and concludes that his pursuit of literary quality over explicit social commitment reflects a different conception of literature’s purpose rather than elitism.

The Conclusion, organized under the heading of “Metatext,” synthesizes the book’s findings under three overarching themes. First, Picerni addresses the question “Is there a workers’ literature to speak of?” He acknowledges that the authors studied do not write primarily to foster class consciousness or produce socially critical exposés, but rather to write something meaningful for their own lives. Yet their shared characteristics: the formative experience of labour and migration, the negotiation of structural inequalities, the encounter with mediators and institutions, make their writings relatable to each other and to the broader experiences of their class. Second, Picerni argues that contemporary workers’ literature has a history and a tradition: the gulf between pre- and post-1980s workers’ literature is real, but many issues raised in the early twentieth century — including authorship, the relationship between art and society, and the challenge to dominant aesthetics — remain operative and are internal constituents of a dialectical totality rather than separate phenomena. Third, Picerni takes up the relationship between the singular and the collective through Guo Jinniu’s image of the “massively single number” (pangda de danshu): the “I” in migrant workers’ literature can be read as an “us” representing any worker. The practice of worker authors, in its “in-betweenness,” as neither fully “outsider” nor fully “core,” neither purely “Earthly” nor “Elevated”, challenges the dominant literary field’s categories and opens “meaningful visions for an emancipated future” (p219).

The book’s strengths notwithstanding, it also raises questions that merit further discussion. Picerni himself acknowledges that the PLG, by virtue of its collective and self-managed dimension, is “atypical” among worker writers in China today, who more often than not operate individually rather than in organized groups. One might ask whether the PLG’s unique institutional ecology, with its sustained engagement with mediators from Beijing’s cultural establishment, limits the generalizability of certain findings to the broader landscape of migrant worker writing, particularly those in the Pearl River Delta who developed under different institutional configurations. While Picerni draws general conclusions with appropriate caution, the tension between the PLG’s representativeness and its singularity occasionally leaves the reader wanting more explicit comparison. Moreover, while the book’s fieldwork ends in early 2020, the landscape of Chinese worker writing has continued to evolve rapidly (consider, for instance, the emergence of the “new mass literature” (新大众文艺) in recent years and the PLG’s core members have been recruited as representatives of this new movement, however problematic and debatable that framework may be). One hopes that future work will extend Picerni’s framework to these developments, including the growing prominence of platform and gig economy workers as literary subjects.

Furthermore, while Chapter 1 admirably traces a genealogy of workers’ literature across the twentieth century, Picerni’s treatment of Mao-era worker writers remains too swift. Applying the same context-text-metatext triad he deploys for the PLG authors to the Mao-era writers yields striking similarities: cultural mediators—editors, literary advisors, and cultural cadres—shaped not only what Mao-era worker writers published but also how they conceived of their own authorship. A more granular treatment of these parallels that reads Mao-era worker writers as individuals navigating their own formative processes within distinct, if state-orchestrated, modes of literary production, would have strengthened the very argument Picerni advances regarding the continuities between pre- and post-1980s workers’ literature.

These observations, however, do not detract from the book’s considerable achievements. Chinese Worker Writersis the first English-language monograph on the Picun Literature Group, and it sets a high standard for future scholarship in the field. By combining literary theory, close textual reading, sustained fieldwork, and extensive engagement with Chinese-language scholarship, Picerni has produced a work that will be essential reading for scholars of Chinese literature, working-class studies, and anyone interested in the intersection of class and cultural production in contemporary China and beyond.

References

Connery, Christopher. Review of Writing to the Rhythm of Labor, by Benjamin Kindler. MCLC Resource Center, 17 Sept. 2025, u.osu.edu/mclc/2025/09/17/rhythm-of-labor-review/. [Maybe change this to the positionspolitics.org/praxis citation?)

van Crevel, Maghiel. “I and We in Picun: The Making of Chinese Poet Xiao Hai.” Positions: Asia Critique, vol. 31, no. 2, 2023, pp. 303–31.

Luka Lei Zhang holds a PhD in English from Nanyang Technological University and is a faculty member at Chengdu University. Her research specializes in Asian Studies, with a focus on socialist and working-class literature, Southeast Asian Studies, and migrant workers’ cultural production. She is also a translator and the editor of the anthology Asian Workers’ Stories (2024).

Cao, What do Sinophone Studies scholars want? 

Upon receiving this piece, we, the editors of praxis, verified the identity of the author/s. We respect their desire to remain anonymous, given the sensitive topic. We identified them only by a surname.

Scholars of Sinophone Studies have long critiqued imperialism, but by their actions, they need it. Sinophone Studies scholars have long argued against a world that wants colonialism, but by their actions, actually-existing colonialism isn’t worth the fuss. 

If not, then why have the vast majority of Sinophone Studies scholars, particularly those in positions of leadership, refused to assume a critical public position against Howard Chiang’s acceptance of the Dan David Prize? By now, the facts regarding the Dan David Prize and Chiang’s decision are well established by the several documents disseminated in the Boycott Dan David Prize Campaign: the “Open Letter to the Society of Sinophone Studies regarding Howard Chiang’s Acceptance of the Dan David Prize”; “The Dan David Prize and Liberal Zionist Academic Washing: An Explainer”; and “History of the DDP and its Dissidents”. 

Perhaps Sinophone Studies scholars merely want for courage to draw the line at a leading scholar using the Sinophone Studies project to rehabilitate collaboration with a genocidal state. Perhaps Sinophone Studies scholars believe that opposing Howard Chiang’s genocide-washing could endanger their own careers. If the latter is true, if scholars are reasonably afraid to critique their collaborationist colleague and stand for Palestinian lives, then that speaks to the unsalvageable character of Sinophone Studies as an intellectual community. But that still does not explain the silence among many, many scholars who enjoy tenure and positions of leadership in Sinophone Studies. Surely, among them, there are scholars who oppose the genocide as well as their own academic field being financially bound to collaboration with it. Have these leaders not considered that, by assuming a critical public position, they would not only claw back the credibility of Sinophone Studies, but do so in a way that offers legitimacy to the junior scholars, contingent scholars, and current graduate students who have evidently risked much in standing against Chiang’s actions?  

Yet the leading lights of Sinophone Studies, always keen to announce their career milestones, stay silent. Perhaps this silence is purposive. Perhaps Sinophone studies needs the imperialist logic that has wrought the “Howard Chiang [Blood Money] Research Fund”. We may certainly dispute whether, in the past, Sinophone Studies, with its fair-weather commitments to “decenter China” and champion the “marginalized,” was a project coherent with U.S. imperialism. However, what the Chiang affair demonstrates is that Sinophone Studies has now become part of U.S.–Israeli imperialism, with its attendant pinkwashing, colonialism, and genocide. It has become this not just through the actions of Chiang (though Chiang plays a decisive role and should be duly recognized for this, his latest career milestone), but through the complicit silence of the Society of Sinophone Studies scholars and, more broadly, the unwillingness of Sinophone scholars at all levels of the academy to draw the line at genocide collaboration within their own field.  

Perhaps the senior scholars who choose to stay silent on the Chiang affair should be named. They owe an explanation for their tacit complicity. But today, this is not our concern. This is, in fact, not a question of individual actions. Howard Chiang is also of little interest, as an individual. Chiang is only the symptom of a broader phenomenon in Sinophone Studies and well beyond — that of scholars who cherish their position at any and all cost to their positionality.

The positionality of Sinophone Studies has been long developed through critiques of imperialism. How quickly such critiques evaporate when a monetary award is presented that rehabilitates collaboration with the Israeli state. In accepting this money, Howard Chiang has embraced a new position as friend to imperialism. His action also makes him an implicit foe to the countless students and faculty across the United States, Europe, and beyond who have risked and often suffered consequences for demanding the end of Israeli occupation and genocide. But most egregiously, Chiang is positioned as institutionally hostile to Palestinian lives. Given this, one could be forgiven for believing that Chiang also placed himself at odds with the Society of Sinophone Studies, given its June 15, 2021 commitment to the international Boycott, Sanctions, and Divestment (BDS) movement. What a statement they composed, decrying Israel for settler-colonialism and apartheid. These declarations are only good, however, when followed by meaningful action.

Chiang’s defiance of commitments to BDS within his field and the near-categorical silence of Sinophone Studies scholars marks a transformational moment in Sinophone Studies. It signals the incorporation of U.S.–Israeli imperialism as a structuring, material condition for the future of the field. In addition, the categorical silence imposed around the Chiang affair inscribes this material condition as an ideological norm. Silence on the Chiang affair and all it importunes is no longer a question of individual temerity; it is evidently a condition for being part of the Sinophone Studies community.

This community has generally developed its intellectual project through engagements with postcolonial studies, extending to examinations of queer and trans identity in communities defined as Sinophone. This has been a salient dimension of Howard Chiang’s own scholarship. In accepting the DDP, Chiang has posed a material condition (collaboration with the Israeli state) that reconfigures queer studies within the Sinophone field. Chiang has institutionally fused queer studies to genocide rehabilitation. He does this as Israel continues its bloody colonization of the West Bank and Gaza. Chiang has therefore removed the “post” from “postcolonial,” baptizing queer studies in the blood of colonial violence.  

Jasbir Puar and numerous other critics of Israeli “pinkwashing” have shown the systematic hijacking of queer identity used to legitimize Israeli authority over Palestinians (who are duly smeared as anti-queer). Chiang’s own self-named research fund is now unambiguously inscribed in that pinkwashing logic. This material collaboration by a leading figure of queer studies and its tacit acceptance by the Sinophone Studies community marks a major transformation in how we must regard queer Sinophone Studies. Howard Chiang’s pinkwashing is therefore significant –– if precedented and unexceptional (though allowing that an award be named after yourself is exceptionally tacky).  

Is this what Sinophone Studies scholars want? If Howard Chiang’s actions were received with critique and reflection among the broader community of Sinophone Studies scholars, then this would be a pertinent question. In the face of enduring silence despite numerous efforts at dialogue and blistering critiques, it can only be reasonably concluded that yes, this is what the community wants. And irrespective of what individual scholars may think of what they want, this is now what Sinophone Studies is.  

Howard Chiang is only a symptom of Sinophone Studies as a project bereft of a critical position on the most incisive issue of our present. Sinophone studies scholars will not critique imperialism, colonialism, and pinkwashing –– to say nothing of genocide –– when the call is coming from inside the house. Now, the material organization of Sinophone Studies is bound to its former objects of critique. In the absence of any clear evidence to the contrary, Sinophone Studies scholars are willing to accept the price of collaboration.  

Of course, the true price is and always was paid by the people of Palestine. From the heights of Jade Mountain, it must be difficult to hear them. 

Andrew Grant, Corridor Catastrophe: Climate Change and Deadly Logistics in the Himalayas

On August 26th, a powerful billow of wind coursed through the Lende River valley at the border between China and Nepal, tearing trees from their precarious cliffside holds. Seconds later, a debris flow of liquified glacial ice and rock shot through the valley, scouring the landscape and gaining speed and material as it flowed downstream. Reaching speeds upwards of 180 kilometers an hour, the debris flow would wipe out entire towns and devastate roads and hydropower stations. Thousands would be tragically buried under a cascade of water, rock, silt, twisted rebar, and concrete.1

The economies of the affected Nepalese towns closest to the border are oriented towards tourism and the work of business logistics. Rasuwagadhi, the first populated area to be destroyed by the Lende-Bhotekoshi-Trishuli River catastrophe, is one of a handful of border crossing areas that has emerged as an urbanized corridor supporting Sino-Nepalese trade and dominated by the importation of Chinese goods.

The tragic deaths of residents in the towns of Timure, Ghatekhola, and Syaprubesi – all part of Nepal’s Rasuwa District – are inextricably linked to the presence of the logistics corridor. The concentration of peoples in the lower valley, just proximate to the river, was not an indigenous settlement pattern but stemmed from the creation of labor opportunities tied to the off-and-on again border junction. The logistical connection between China and Nepal produced new social and commercial spaces that sat uneasily amid a landscape sensitive to climate change and the continuous erosion of natural and artificial surfaces. Moreover, through its current geopolitical and geoeconomic strategy, China is waging an on-going war on the Himalayan landscape through logistical deployment. Given intractable environmental unpredictability and technological limitations, this war places many Nepalis in death’s way.

The Chinese border gate at Rasuwa. The pictured bridge was destroyed by a Glacial Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF) in 2025. An 18th century fort can be seen at the bottom of the frame. The August gangbal destroyed all man-made structures at this border and river junction. Photo by author, 2024.

Chinese commitments to outward development are rooted in a cluster of economic and political priorities. Chinese domestic manufacturers need external markets to maintain their growth and success, and the Chinese state consolidates and projects its sovereignty through the construction of infrastructure in its borderlands (Ye 2020; Leibold 2026). Border connections to neighboring countries require securitizing borderlands territories, building and rebuilding infrastructures, and making territorial edges more reachable by the state.

Beyond economic and political domination, the development of Chinese-linked infrastructure and trade flows brings a mixture of propaganda, coercion, and mundane familiarity with China to neighboring states. Logistics thus supports an emergent geopolitical order for the “Community of Shared Destiny” (Ch. mingyun gongtongti), in which, theoretically, all countries entangled in China’s development programs enjoy shared prosperity. The Nepalese government also desires the trade flows and development that connections to China provide. Import duties, particularly on EV cars, form a significant portion of national revenue. Indeed, natural disasters like floods and landslides have been shown to have measurable negative impacts on Nepal’s public revenue (Khatri et al. 2026). Cooperation with China has also helped successive Nepali governments balance the mercurial relationship with India, which has used its influence to punish Nepalese governments for their relationships with the Chinese government and Chinese firms (Murton and Lord 2017). Balancing the relationship between China, India, and powerful states outside the region are part of contemporary strategic statecraft, so it is a mistake to reduce contemporary Nepali politics to the Chinese sphere of influence (DiCarlo and Paudel 2025). Nonetheless, the relationship with China provides massive amounts of cheap goods that can be found in homes, restaurants, businesses, restrooms, and other milieux of everyday life. China’s growing influence in politics and life is undeniable.

Before the August 26th disaster, known as a gangbal in the Tamang language, Rasuwa could have been considered a showcase for logistical connection. Concrete, asphalt, and bridges had enabled container trucks, painted lorries, and EV cars piloted by locals to make the crossing between the two countries. Chinese developers were behind the dry port and recently completed customs hall. From these developments, new businesses were able to form, and new patterns of livelihood had taken hold. Residents new and old worked with the Ward Chief for opportunities to labor at the Dry Port, sharing the payment for packing and unpacking trucks. For these laborers, the Dry Port in Timure was an alternative to meager farming incomes or alternatives such as moving to Kathmandu, a Gulf State, or Europe. Families strategized about who would go where and how to find income. For those that stayed behind in Timure, or that moved in from surrounding rural areas, it was important to be close to the Dry Port to participate in any economic activity. Subsequently, farmers descended from the upper farms to river-side housing and outsiders rented cheap rooms along the road. The logistical route became an urban corridor exposed to disaster.

Logistics is violence. The science of business logistics is genealogically connected to military development, and its prioritization in contemporary capitalism has produced new modes and manners of violence (Cowen 2014). If logistics has helped wage “social war” on organized labor, it has also invited, enticed, and entrapped populations around the world into dangerous labor environments on container ships, fishing trawlers, and in mines, factories, and warehouses. It has also, as the case of Rasuwa makes clear, trapped laborers in dry port-adjacent urban corridors. These corridors are sites where Chinese construction firms wage a continuous war against montane geology. By blasting and leveling, cementing and reinforcing, construction firms open the supply routes for Chinese imports to pour into Nepal.

Achille Mbembe (2019) has argued that one site of the emergence of modern sovereignty is the separation of the human subject from nature and the linking of the colonized subject to uncivilized nature. Twentieth-century Marxist states saw nature as an object to be tamed, sometimes with great violence and lethal human exertion, such as the Soviet Transpolar Railway. Natural environments and prison-laborers were both destroyed in efforts to overcome technically difficult permafrost conditions. Contemporary capitalism, in all its varieties, also tames nature, offering environmental assessments and land compensation to ameliorate the violence of logistics.

On the one hand, China’s infrastructure projects on the Tibetan Plateau and in the Himalayas have been successful. Before 2006, there were many critics of the Qinghai-Tibet Railway, at that point terminating in Lhasa. Permafrost conditions were to make the undertaking an impossible feat: cyclic freezing and thawing presented risks. Ultimately, engineers devised diverse active and passive tools to stabilize permafrost cooling and heating, including 36 kilometers of sunk thermal piles (Qin and Zheng 2010). More recently, rail-building projects in western Tibet have enabled logistical connection between Lhasa and Shigatse. Today modern tarmac highways connect that city to the town of Kyirong, near the border with Nepal, and up to Rasuwagadhi itself. China CAMC engineering has submitted feasibility studies for rail connections to Kathmandu and Tibet Tian Lu Company Limited (Mulmi et al. 2023) was rewarded a Chinese-financed contract to widen and pave the road from the Rasuwagadhi border to Syaprubesi. Combined with the dry port and border security cooperation, a key objective has been to eliminate logistics frictions between the two countries. Trade between China and Nepal has increased significantly over the last decade, as Chinese exports have more than doubled while Nepal’s exports have remained stagnant. Chinese SOEs have also been the big winners for construction projects, with investments typically being conditional on their execution by Chinese firms (Mulmi et al. 2023).

On the other hand, on-going development has carved-up alpine meadows in Tibet, exposing soils to more erosion. In Nepal road and hydropower development destabilizes cliffsides. Simultaneously, cryosphere geographies, are subject to global climate necropolitics (Sultana 2022; DeBoom 2021). In the Himalayas, glaciers are rapidly melting away, opening rock faces and glaciated soils to erosion. Between the war of logistics and the anthropogenic destruction of Himalayan glaciers, the landscape of the Himalayas suffers slow violence, a siege of geographic integrity that places local populations in a state of precarity as they live in the shadows of the supply chains they service. Unlike economies of climate necropolitics that despoil spaces and injure laborers where crucial minerals can be extracted for the green supply chain, the necropolitics of Sino-Nepali logistics shifts rapidly from a slower structural violence to sudden calamity, such as the recent gangbal.

The necropolitics of supply chain logistics must be understood in relation to its biopolitical counterpart (Peters, et al., 2025). At the Sino-Nepali border at Rasuwagadhi, China had loomed large as it conducted the conduct of the border. During my fieldwork there in 2024 and 2025, I learned about pervasive CCTV, secret agents, extraterritorial “concerns” over activity across in Timure, and occasional beatings of Nepali citizens. Chinese activities concerned with Nepalese citizens’ conduct sought to discipline social activity and thereby smooth the circulation and ensure supply chain security. The PRC’s Ministry of Finance promoted development projects that have now been washed away, including the dry port and primary schools.

Street scene in the Timure. Local economic life tightly hugged the road that divided the town to the dry port below the road and just off frame. Photo by author, 2024.

If China is concerned about the life of Nepal’s citizens near its border, and seeks to include Nepal in the Community of Shared Destiny, why the exposure to death? The answer likely lies in the geopolitical and geo-economic goal of expanding Chinese influence among its neighboring states and in breaking Indian hegemony in South Asia (Grant 2025). To accomplish this, logistics must exercise sovereignty over Himalayan landscapes. The most important part of the life-sustaining circulations that China seeks to enliven are an expansion of a Sino-centered geo-economic sphere. In the view of Chinese developmental authorities, nothing must stop deepening economic entanglement, despite ongoing problems with an unstable landscape that reshapes with every monsoon season. Deadly incidents like the 2015 earthquake and the 2025 destruction of the Rasuwagadhi border-spanning bridge have only served to encourage further the war of logistics on the environment, rather than deter efforts at reconstruction.

The promise of infrastructure in the high Himalayas, crossed by narrow gorges, capped with a sensitive cryosphere, subject to seismic activity, and soaked by the unpredictable rains of the monsoon season, necessitates technological advancement, confidence, and prudence. As Nepal’s public works projects have lagged behind, the Chinese have seemed to possess all of this. The war against nature is a war they appear ready to wage. There are positive outcomes of this disaster. Strong connections exist between Nepali and Chinese authorities and scientists that sharpen and improve disaster prediction and response. Environmental and technical collaborations can be viewed viewed as forms of ‘deep neighboring’ that can even help local concerns in these borderlands reach the state (Saxer 2023). Recent assessments have provided ways forward to mitigate GLOF disasters and even blast newly formed lakes to prevent the destruction of future communities.

Nevertheless, the August gangbal disaster demands we acknowledge the realities of logistical and climate violence. Border connectives create urban corridors into which Nepal’s rural populations have migrated. No amount of political confidence or engineering techno-solutions seem able to overcome the sheer challenge posed by Himalayan topography and its melting glaciers. Today, Nepalese authorities are appealing to the United Nations, China, and other sources to help rebuild devastated areas. The economic dependency that trans-Himalayan logistics has created between China and Nepal seems to necessitate that logistical links are rebuilt, bigger and better than before: the Community of Shared Destiny must be forged.

Yet with the resuscitation of this biopolitical circulation returns the specter of the necropolitical: the new Chinese order in South Asia is being built upon the destruction of Himalayan environments. The logistical war on Rasuwagadhi’s landscape is one that will be “won” only at great cost, as new blasting, bulldozing, and paving amid a collapsing cryosphere continues to expose borderlands peoples to disaster death.

Andrew Grant is Assistant Professor of Geography in the Department of History, Geography and Legal Studies at the University of Tampa

References

Cowen, Deborah. 2014. The Deadly Life of Logistics: Mapping the Violence of Global Trade. 1st ed. University of Minnesota Press.

DeBoom, Meredith J. 2021. “Climate Necropolitics: Ecological Civilization and the Distributive Geographies of Extractive Violence in the Anthropocene.” Annals of the American Association of Geographers 111 (3): 900–912. https://doi.org/10.1080/24694452.2020.1843995.

DiCarlo, Jessica, and Dinesh Paudel. 2026. “Infrastructural Polyalignment and Himalayan Geopolitics: Subjugation, Small-State Agency, and Regional Competition in Nepal.” Third World Quarterly 47 (13): 2727–45. https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2025.2522292.

Grant, Andrew. 2025. “Expanding China’s Geopolitical Influence through Peripheral Communication – Mapping China’s Strategic Space.” Borderlands. Mapping China’s Strategic Space, August 13. https://strategicspace.nbr.org/expanding-chinas-geopolitical-influence-through-peripheral-communication/.

Khatri, Abiral, Austin Lord, and Jakob Steiner. 2026. “Climate Risks to Nepal’s Energy Transition: Loss and Damage from a Glacial Lake Disaster Disrupting the Trans-Himalayan EV Supply Chain • Stimson Center.” Stimson Center, August 4. https://www.stimson.org/2026/climate-risks-to-nepals-energy-transition-loss-and-damage-from-a-glacial-lake-disaster-disrupting-the-trans-himalayan-ev-supply-chain/.

Leibold, James. 2026. “Infrastructure Nationalism and Sovereignty by Settlement in Tibet: The Case of Xiaokang Border Villages.” China Information, September 17, 0920203X261477237. https://doi.org/10.1177/0920203X261477237.

Maskey, Aayush, and Suloja Khadka. 2024. “Pandemic Pulse: A Comparative Analysis of Nepal-China Import-Export Trends Pre-and Post-COVID (2015-2023).” SSRN Electronic Journal, ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5021962.

Mbembe, Achille. 2019. Necropolitics. Duke University Press.

Mulmi, Amish Raj, Arpan Gelal, Anil Giri, Raunab Singh Khatri, and Milan Acharya. 2023. China’s Emergence in Nepal’s Infrastructure: Status, Issues and Challenges. Centre for Social Inclusion and Federalism (CESIF).

Murton, Galen. 2016. “A Himalayan Border Trilogy: The Political Economies of Transport Infrastructure and Disaster Relief between China and Nepal.” Cross-Currents: East Asian History and Culture Review 1 (18): 97–109.

Murton, Galen, and Austin Lord. 2020. “Trans-Himalayan Power Corridors: Infrastructural Politics and China’s Belt and Road Initiative in Nepal.” Political Geography 77 (March): 102100. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2019.102100.

Peters, Freya, Nick Clare, and Thom Davies. 2025. “Necropolitics and Geography.” Progress in Human Geography 49 (5): 466–88. https://doi.org/10.1177/03091325251348613.

Qin, Yinghong, and Bo Zheng. 2010. “The Qinghai–Tibet Railway: A Landmark Project and Its Subsequent Environmental Challenges.” Environment, Development and Sustainability 12 (5): 859–73. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-009-9228-x.

Saxer, Martin. 2023. Places in Knots: Remoteness and Connectivity in the Himalayas and Beyond. Cornell University Press.

Sultana, Farhana. 2022. “The Unbearable Heaviness of Climate Coloniality.” Political Geography 99 (November): 102638. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2022.102638.

Ye, Min. 2020. The Belt Road and Beyond: State-Mobilized Globalization in China: 1998–2018. Cambridge University Press.

Youth Innovation Lab. 2026. Mountain Tsunami. Kathmandu.

 

Benjamin Kindler reviews Fabio Lanza, Urban Revolution: People’s Communes in Beijing

Fabio Lanza, Urban Revolution: People’s Communes in Beijing (Cambridge University Press, 2026).

In the depths of this engrossing study, Fabio Lanza notes a curious fact in one of his archival sources. In a document whose title reads “Provisions on some issues concerning the urban people’s communes at this stage”, the characters adding “centered on laboring women” have been erased by the editor. Whether this change was accepted in the final version, or how else to assess the flick of the editor’s pen, Lanza tells us, we do not know. (206 fn14). Without – as historians often say – reading too much into the sources, it would seem that this archival trace is fitting as an end to the book: it tells us something about the closure of the dramatic social experiment that was the Great Leap Forward (GLF). The crossing-out of the category of woman marks the end of the urban Great Leap and of the urban communes, which, for Lanza, comprised the most radical attempt to transform the conditions of the everyday during the course of the Chinese Revolution. This telling anecdote at the end of the book marks a perhaps deliberate contrast with the opening of the first chapter, in which a woman, Wang Zhijie, recounts the moment when she experienced the exceeding the category of “housewife” to which she had been limited. At the beginning, then: the opening-up and radical expansion of the category of woman as a site of indeterminacy; at the end, the foreclosure of that category as a language of politics and struggle. In between, a contested, evolving process in which the possibility of a transformed life entered into flickering visibility at decisive moments.

This is a book about the possibility and aspiration of a radical transformation of the everyday, understood with the aid of Henri Lefebvre as the (seemingly) trivial details of the quotidian that often bear on our experience as gendered subjects. For Lanza, the GLF was unparalleled in its ambitions for such transformation. He uncovers these ambitions by recovering the experience of the urban people’s communes in Beijing (1958-1962). The everyday, for Lanza, is not simply that which is the empirical immediacy or “real” that less sophisticated historians have tried to reveal. Rather, the everyday for him constitutes the shifting set of relations that is constantly transformed through the process of revolution itself. In this sense, the practice of socialist revolution for Lanza is by its very nature an everyday affair.

Across five densely-argued chapters, the book treats us to the evolution of a socialist project of everyday transformation. The formal arrangement of the book is a mark of great sophistication in its own right. It is not a strict chronological trajectory, but rather an account that manages to move between the details of emergent policies as actualized in state archives together with the often complex and even esoteric theoretical debates that emerged in the same period. Whereas chapters one, three and five mark a roughly chronological sequence, chapter two brings us into contact with Chinese Marxist theorists who grappled with how to conceptualize socialism in theoretical and policy terms as China was shifting away from a Soviet orthodoxy, whereas chapter four brings us into contact with a particular community of workers — barbers — who emerge as unexpected protagonists and subjects of the GLF. In and across these moments, Lanza develops an account of a locality – Beijing – in the midst of an unprecedented upheaval. The picture of the urban GLF that emerges is of an uneven attempt to provide new social services that would support the entry of women into new occupations beyond the home, accompanied by an ongoing attempt to theorize that process and its relation to the tasks of socialist transition.

Lanza’s study suggests the continuation of the theoretical and political interests that have structured his previous writing. Beyond Lefebvre, his engagement above all with the work of Jacques Ranciere is important; Rancière, like Lanza, is concerned with the moments of radical egalitarian politics in which subjects step beyond the social locations to which they have been assigned. In his first book, Behind the Gate, Lanza developed an account of radical egalitarian politics in relation to students, who, in the act of refusing the position of student as the disciplined subject of the university, moved onto the terrain of political struggle during the 1910s and 1920s. In the current book, the subject positions and locations that came to be troubled (albeit not enough, it seems) during the GLF were the “worker.” Indeed, as Lanza asserts, the GLF re-posed the question of “who was actually included in the category of the ‘worker’” (7). Moments of radical excess – of stepping beyond assigned subject locations – are, for Lanza as for Rancière, the stuff of politics itself.

Yet the more radical orientation of this book is the way it ties the theoretical vocabulary of the everyday and the subject to that of gendered experience and the role of women in the Chinese Revolution. The problem of the everyday is a gendered experience, not least in the way the “trivial” matters that are often dismissed as beyond the realm of “real” politics are themselves gendered. In this respect, Lanza’s work draws on the work of a number of feminist historians working in the field of Chinese Studies, such as Tani Barlow, Gail Hershatter, Kimberley Manning, Wang Zheng, Rebecca Karl, Dong Yige and others.

One major structuring category of the book is framed through the question of reproduction, which is a slippery category both for the Marxist tradition generally as for Lanza himself. It is thus worth pausing here to note the varying and distinct ways in which the category emerges in Lanza’s treatment. The most persistent concern is with the practices of gendered reproduction that comprise what Marxist feminists have termed the “hidden abode” of everyday life and which provide the substratum on which factory-based forms of wage labor rely. These can be profoundly material (preparing and eating food, sleeping, washing, etc.) but they also encompass the emotional and bodily practices that produce and sustain us as subjects (care, sex, etc.). In Lanza’s argument, Chinese Marxists did not generate a specific concept of reproduction insofar as references to reproduction as 再生产 always indicate a narrower and more circumscribed concept derived from the Soviet theoretical edifice (173), 2 namely the expanded reproduction of the productive forces through socialist accumulation. Nor, crucially, Lanza acknowledges, are the forms of gendered reproduction just listed equally available for collectivization (171). Lanza therefore reaches repeatedly for the theoretical resources of Marxist and autonomist feminists, notably Mariarosa Dalla Costa, who have foregrounded the gendered everyday and its associated practices of reproduction as central to Marxist analysis.

Running alongside this feminist account of reproduction, there is another concept of reproduction, not opposed to the first but that denotes a distinct theoretical logic. When,, in chapter two, Lanza writes that, with the proliferation of bourgeois right, “bourgeois forms of social relations will continue to reproduce themselves, endlessly re-creating new inequalities and differences incompatible” (98) he is invoking a theoretical logic and tradition formally distinct from feminist accounts of gendered reproduction, and more closely orientated towards a part of the French Marxist tradition as associated with such theorists as Louis Althusser, Etienne Balibar and Charles Bettelheim, all men who engage(d) in various ways with the Chinese Revolution. They were concerned, as Lanza observes, with an understanding of socialism as an extended and non-contemporaneous period of transition in which capitalist forms reproduced on the basis of socialism itself co-exist with incipient communist modes and relations. Multiple significations of reproduction are thus in operation in this book.

In the Marxist tradition,  these different accounts of reproduction have never quite met, insofar as their points of departure have always remained largely different from each other: Dalla Costa being concerned with the everyday forms of violence and oppression that exist within the family and the insurgent possibilities of new feminist movements rooted in the powers of gendered subjectivity, whereas Althusser and his disciples  begin from the role of the Ideological State Apparatuses in the reproduction of subjects, in which the school takes on the decisive role. When, then, we ask the question of what or who is being reproduced when we talk of reproduction, the list becomes expansive: social relations, temporalities, modes of production, bodies, subjects, systems of gendered power, and so on. At another level, therefore, beyond the initial question of the everyday, Lanza’s study is an attempt to think these different modes and questions of reproduction together. We are led to confront the question: what is the relation between the transformation of the conditions of the reproduction of life through the reworking (if not abolition) of the family form and the provision of new collective services on the one hand, and, on the other, inhibiting the tendencies towards the reproduction of capitalist social relations?

Just as the divergent strands of reproduction have never quite met in Marxist theoretical analysis generally speaking, so too, it seems, they never did meet in the course of the GLF and the Chinese Revolution more generally. 3 The (male) theorists who intervened in discussions around bourgeois right did not, after all, factor social reproduction into their discussions. The effective use to which Lanza mobilizes the category of “reproduction” might, here, have benefited from an explicit interrogation of how much work that category has done within the Marxist tradition, and how that work relates to the absence of an explicit consideration of “social reproduction” as a theoretical category in the Chinese Revolution. Yet Lanza is too good and sensitive a reader to simply mourn the fact that the Chinese Revolution did not generate the theoretical categories that we might like. Instead, he diagnoses the shortcomings behind the urban communes.

If the common sense that occupies discussions around the GLF too often blames it as a movement of foolish excess always bound to failure, Lanza instead locates its shortcomings in the fact that it was not feminist enough. When women exited from the home to work in commune enterprises, he shows, they did so in conditions where their external labor continued to be viewed, remunerated and disciplined in highly gendered terms (135), within a Taylorist logic (146) that was orientated towards the singular aim of increasing production (157). In his most incisive formulation, Lanza notes: “…as the history of urban collectivization proves, the problem of gender equality, even among workers, could not be reduced to one of self-awareness; rather, it was grounded on a systematic devaluation of any work performed by women, in the home as well as in the factory” (158). And this, in turn, points me towards the most generous aspect of the book, in the way it poses the question of who or what counts as a proper site of theoretical production.

There is plenty of analysis in the book that coheres to accepted definitions of theory and philosophy (chapter 2 especially) in the way Lanza pursues close engagements with Marxist analysis and reads that work with the seriousness it deserves. But so too throughout the book there is a sense of the imminence of theory to everyday socialist practice, not only in the way debates around, say, bourgeois right informed the Leap, but also in the way that the subjects of the urban communes evoke desires, fantasies, even visions of utopia that are themselves instances of theory-making. When he writes of how the frenzied orientation towards production eliminated the time available to women amounted to a “devaluation” of their desires (163), and when, in doing so, he draws on the theoretical insights of Dalla Costa, we should, I believe, see this not as an instance of reading “Chinese history” through “Western theory” but rather as a set of feminist echoes across space, embodied in the expression of desire for that most simple but elusive of pleasures: time outside of and beyond the demands of production, in the home or in the factory.

What, then, remains, to borrow a question from another socialist feminist, Christa Wolf? This is of course a book about the Great Leap Forward. Lanza notes that even whilst later moments in the Chinese Revolution witnessed the persistence of certain questions and challenges that emerged in the GLF, the Great Leap was unparalleled in the way it sought – however partially, however unsuccessfully – to address problems of the everyday through reproduction.

 In this regard, it would be remiss not to at least touch on the other moment of radical Maoist politics, namely the Cultural Revolution. In a recent panel discussion on the “late” Cultural Revolution at the Association of Asian Studies meeting in Vancouver (March 2026), Lanza responded to a paper by Harlan Chambers on “struggle drama” by noting that short dramatic texts featuring women protagonists who take up political struggle are curious for their lack of narrative content relating to reproduction or indeed production as such.4 As a descriptive statement, Lanza was quite right, and my instinct is that this was intended as a critical remark about the texts in question. Yet, if we insist on the term of reproduction itself not just as referring to who does the dishes but also as the production of subject positions and subjectivities, then, seen in those terms, the Cultural Revolution clearly was also about reproduction – in the way the critique of Confucianism under the auspices of the Criticize Lin Biao Criticize Confucius campaign was directly concerned with the ideological reproduction of a hierarchical gendered order, and in the way that new subject positions such as the “youth”/qingnian or “revolutionary successor”/jiebanren (movingly recalled by Zhong Xueping and Wang Zheng amongst other contributors to the volume Some of Us) offered new modes of subject formation that stood at least partially outside a gendered order. Or, to pose this question from a different angle, we may also ask the question of what other theoretical categories were absent from the Great Leap Forward alongside a fully developed concept of social reproduction, in which case we find the surprising absence of a language of class and class struggle under socialism (distinct from the logic of bourgeois right, which does not, in the Great Leap period, admit the formation of a new bourgeoisie in the party) insofar, as, during the Great Leap, the tasks of overcoming the class divisions of pre-1949 society were understood to have been largely completed. It is, by contrast, the return of class struggle in the Cultural Revolution and indeed its totalizing function that also allows it to incorporate a set of feminist concerns around the persistence of patriarchal logics in the everyday and their associated modes of subject formation, with a corresponding interrogation of the family form that encompasses a more ruptural set of possibilities.

Perhaps the point, then, is that reproduction in the Cultural Revolution is precisely not informed by production and reproduction in the sense identified by Lanza in the Great Leap; nor is it indeed informed by the desire for free time. Rather, it comes to be about politics (a class politics that – in uneven and complex fashion – also subsumes and incorporated an anti-patriarchal politics) in a way that the Great Leap Forward did not address. Which is to say, reproduction in the Cultural Revolution is about politics as militant, antagonistic practice, politics about desire in a new form, where we see the emergence of a new configuration of the subject beyond what even the women of the Great Leap might have imagined. Does that subject have a name? Perhaps her name is Jiang Qing.

Benjamin Kindler is the author of Writing to the Rhythm of Labor(Columbia University Press, 2025) and is currently teaching as Assistant Professor in Cultural Studies at Lingnan University in Hong Kong. He has written a number of articles on Mao-era China, and is also a prolific translator from the Chinese into English of texts by prominent socialist intellectuals.

Mingwei Huang reviews Nadine Attewell, Archives of Intimacy: Racial Mixing and Chinese Lives in the Colonial Port City, 1905-1949

Nadine Attewell, Archives of Intimacy: Racial Mixing and Chinese Lives in the Colonial Port City, 1905-1949 (Stanford University Press, 2026).

In the early twentieth century, Chinese migrants, among others from Asia, Africa, the Caribbean, and Europe, flocked to London, Liverpool, and Hong Kong. Nadine Attewell’s luminous Archives of Intimacy transports readers to these vibrant early 20th century dockside worlds and offers a feminist and queer history of relation, one that expands how we understand the global formation of “Chineseness” and write history. Through Attewell’s vast archival research, we encounter Chinese migrant men who married white immigrant women and local women of color, mixed-race Chinese children, elite Eurasian families, and Chinese Caribbean diasporic subjects. The book unfolds across the street corners, laundries, boarding houses, brothels, dance halls, and shops of London’s Limehouse and Liverpool’s Pitt Street neighborhoods. The heterogenous presence of seamen of color, sex workers, and social reformers exceeded the moniker “Chinatown.” Attewell examines the working-class cosmopolitanisms, intimate relations, and everyday acts of solidarity between port city residents to survive the anti-immigrant, racist inhospitalities of interwar Britain under the 1905 Aliens Act. In contrast to British port cities, Attewell also considers the Chinese majority British colony of Hong Kong to highlight a different set of mobilities, intimacies, and forms of Chineseness.

Since the relational turn in the study of race, colonialism, and empire—of which Lisa Lowe’s Intimacies of the Four Continents (2015) is paradigmatic— “relation,” “intimacy,” and “entanglement” have become ubiquitous to the point of losing their analytical specificity. However, in Archives of Intimacy, intimacy and relation are treated with precision. In this book, intimacy is both the stuff of the archives and a heuristic, “a genre of relation,” for bringing together histories of (semi)colonial east Asia, Chinese migration, and imperial Britain. Archives of Intimacy attends “to the fleshy, emplaced particulars of Chinese people’s social lives” (Attewell 3). What makes this book distinctive is its emphasis on the ephemeral, queer forms of relation that are not easily categorizable: same-sex intimacies and transactional sex, homosocial domestic arrangements, “deviant” family formations, and acts and aspirations “not always in accordance with imperial dictates or desires” (Attewell 3). Attewell mobilizes relational terms to write a connected history of colonial capitalist modernity that brings Chinese people across imperial geographies together, shaping and constraining their lives and “wayward itineraries” but never determining them. While it is easy to romanticize intimacies, the intimacies in this book are in the service of Chinese working-class survival and the reproduction of class privilege and imperial power. Interracial intimacy and multiracial conviviality are “material social practices with the potential to proliferate life chances for more people than might otherwise have been supported to survive, let alone thrive” (Attewell 4). Intimacies do not spontaneously spring up whenever racialized people encounter one another but must be laboriously forged through relational work.

Like the pejorative terms “half-caste” and “Chinaman,” “mixed-race” and “Chinese” are terms of identity freighted with racial and geopolitical meanings, and they have not been available for all diasporic subjects to claim. Accordingly, Attewell is careful to not rely on identitarian logics that posit a stable mixed-race Chinese subject and that reify Han-centric, racial nationalist “Chineseness.” Rather, she approaches Chineseness as a cultural text and frames it through relation; subjects become Chinese through their encounters with and ties to others. Refusing to narrow who can claim Chineseness, she emphasizes “the capacity of Chineseness to…mean and do new things.” “Chinese” is a “capaciously descriptive rather than a normative modifier to mark an inheritance or ascription that people may have taken up in any number of ways, or refused altogether” (Attewell 15). Refusing to demarcate and police who is Chinese, Attewell radically expands Chinese into an “inclusive category through which a range of subjects might access care and pleasure” (94). Crucially, Chineseness is not a fixed identity based in lineage and biology, nor a property of the self, but “materializes as a key site of attachment and meaning” (Attewell 75, 93).

In three parts — “Encounters,” “Itineraries,” and “Lifelines” — Attewell tells the singular and collective stories of Chinese men, women, and children, while interrogating the heteronormative, racial ways of knowing that structure their inclusion or absence in the archive. Chapter 1 “Looking Relations” centers a photograph of three mixed-race Chinese girls in London, their names and the provenance of the photograph unknown. Writing against the “archive of pathology,” Attewell attends to the girls’ refusal to be captured on film, attending to their practices of looking, knowing, and relating instead. Chapter 2 “The Queerest Parish in England” examines the promiscuous social relations of Chinese Liverpool and the pressures of white heteronormative respectability on shaping the community’s historical narratives. We meet the memorable Bella Gomes, a neighborhood resident of “Portuguese and Negro blood” who sold sexual services to Chinese migrant men. Gomes is absent from community oral histories despite her sustained presence and the solidarity she offered to the community. Chapter 3 “Everyday Chineseness” theorizes how “Chinese” is relationally produced and lived through the affective, nostalgic medium of food. Chinese mixed-race children felt a sense of identity and belonging through foodstuffs and goods. Practices of nourishment—the devalued yet “necessary work” of social reproduction—formed the bedrock of children’s acculturation and the community’s regeneration.  Continuing Attewell’s attention to child subjects, Chapter 4 “Black and Chinese Liverpool in Relation” analyzes photographs of Asian and Black children playing at school. The children’s relations emblematize the maritime networks that brought African and Chinese men to Liverpool and the possibilities of Afro-Asian conviviality against racial division.

Largely set in Hong Kong, “Itineraries” explores patterns of mobility, settlement, and place-making. Contrasting the working-class cosmopolitanism of previous chapters, Chapter 5 “Relationship on Top of Relationship” turns to the imperial cosmopolitanism of Hong Kong’s elite Eurasian families, including the Cheng family, and the multigenerational reproduction of social influence through marital alliances and pedagogical training. This is also relational work, but in the service of accruing familial privileges within the British colonial capitalist order. In Chapter 6 “Model Students and Problem Children,” we follow doctoral student Irene Cheng as she embarks on dissertation research about working-class Chinese in Limehouse, only to suffer a mental breakdown and change her dissertation topic. Cheng exerts a ghostly presence throughout the book. For Attewell, in perhaps a poignant moment of identification with her subject, Cheng’s breakdown “point[s] to the affordances, costs, and limits of the deeply personal repertoires of knowledge that researchers bring to some projects more than others” (18). Chapter 7 “Exit Strategy” follows the case of Sarah Hing, a mixed Chinese woman born in the United States under the Chinese Exclusion Act, who married a Muslim medical student “of half Chinese and half East Indian blood” in Hong Kong, and was barred from re-entering the US when pregnant. Within the constraints of imperial citizenship, Hing rejected married life and shuttled back and forth the Pacific with her child. These chapters standout in Attewell’s creative reading of colonial archives, pressing at the limits of Cheng’s thesis and Hing’s immigration file to speculate about their interior lives, relations, and experiences as desiring, mixed-race subjects.

 “Lifelines” clarifies the stakes of relational work during the Second World War in occupied Hong Kong and southern China. Chapter 8 “Mixed with the Caribbean” examines how Afro-Chinese Caribbean diasporic returnees mobilized knowledge of Jamaican, Trinidadian, Guianan, and Surinamese social worlds and local Chinese relations to support Britain. It tells the story of Percy Chang, an Afro-Chinese Jamaican who worked as a British intelligence agent in Guangdong where he could stealthily pass as Chinese, and Chang’s fraught ties across the Caribbean and Pearl Delta River worlds. Chapter 9 “A Matter of Life and Death” commemorates the mixed-race Chinese women who engaged in relational, social reproductive work for collective survival. To keep their families together, Chinese women often joined their white British partners in POW camps. They procured foodstuffs, sent parcels, raised children, and engaged in sex work. These everyday acts may not be as legible as rebellions, strikes, and insurgencies, but they resolutely were forms of political action. Throughout the chapters, Attewell insists on Chinese women and girls’ everyday practices of resistance—girls who refused the photographer, women who chose another way—and the social necessity of their relation-making labors. In this way, we can consider Archives of Intimacy as a companion text to Saidiya Hartman’s Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments (2019). Focusing on daughters, wives, aunties, and sex workers, Attewell recasts “ordinary people’s intimate experiments as (counter)archives of global Asian thought and action” (14).

There are many ways to read this book: a social history of early twentieth-century Chinese diasporic life, an Afro-Asian atlas, a people’s history of the port, a feminist manifesto about reproductive labor, a model for writing histories of relation, a collection of community and life histories, among other things. For me, Archives of Intimacy realizes the radical potential for engaging Asian and Asian diasporic studies with feminist and queer theories and methods to imagine usable pasts of connection. It can also be read as a timely blueprint for mutual aid and care in the face of cruel state violence, organized abandonment, imperial war, repressive border regimes, and family separation. An indispensable resource for interdisciplinary methods, Archives of Intimacy offers an exercise in attention: listening at “lower frequencies” (Campt 2017) and reading images for what appears on the edge of the frame or is absented all together. Ethnography is a form of knowledge-production specific to the subjectivity of the ethnographer and their relations with a particular group of people and place. The same is true for the historian. Attewell, herself a mixed-race Chinese diasporic subject, narrates her encounters with the archive and how its silences affected her. Research is relational work, she reminds us. 

References

Attewell, Nadine. 2026. Archives of Intimacy: Racial Mixing and Chinese Lives in the Colonial Port City, 1905-1949. Stanford University Press.

Campt, Tina M. 2017. Listening to Images. Duke University Press.

Hartman, Saidiya. 2018. Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments: Intimate Histories of Riotous Black Girls, Troublesome Women, and Queer Radicals. W. W. Norton & Co.

Lowe, Lisa. 2015. The Intimacies of Four Continents. Duke University Press.

 

Mingwei Huang is Associate Professor, Program in Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies, Dartmouth College. Huang is the author of Reconfiguring Racial Capitalism: South Africa in the Chinese Century (Duke University Press, 2024).